BOT assets used by a private operator remain taxable; a GOCC cannot pass its real property tax exemption through contract assumptions.
Tax exemptions in build-operate-transfer projects do not automatically pass from a government corporation to its private project proponent. Under the BOT Tax Exemption Rule, a government-owned corporation cannot shield privately owned and operated project assets from local real property tax merely because the project will eventually be transferred to the government or because the contract makes the government entity responsible for taxes. For local governments, private power project operators, and public-private partnership participants, the ruling confirms that actual ownership, possession, and beneficial use matter more than contractual tax assumptions.
Background: The Dispute
National Power Corporation entered into an Energy Conversion Agreement with CEPA Pangasinan Electric Limited, later known as Mirant Sual Corporation, for the construction, operation, and maintenance of the Sual Coal-Fired Thermal Power Plant on a build-operate-transfer basis. Under the agreement, NPC assumed responsibility for real property taxes, and it paid those taxes for several years before stopping and claiming exemption under the Local Government Code.
The Province of Pangasinan and the local assessor pursued assessment of the machinery, equipment, buildings, and facilities connected with the power plant. NPC argued that the properties were used for power generation and should enjoy exemptions or preferential assessment treatment; the local assessment boards, the Central Board of Assessment Appeals, and the Court of Tax Appeals rejected that position before the dispute reached the Supreme Court in National Power Corporation v. Province of Pangasinan (G.R. No. 210191, March 4, 2019).
The Supreme Court’s Ruling
The Supreme Court denied NPC’s petition and upheld the local real property tax assessment. The Court held that NPC had no legal personality to question the assessment or claim the tax exemptions and privileges because it was not the owner, possessor, or beneficial user of the subject facilities during the relevant taxable period.
The Court recognized that real property tax may be chargeable not only to an owner but also to the person who has actual and beneficial use and possession of the property. That principle, however, did not help NPC. Under the BOT arrangement, Mirant owned, operated, managed, maintained, and used the power station, machinery, and equipment until the transfer date. NPC’s future ownership and contractual assumption of tax obligations did not make it the actual, direct, exclusive, and beneficial user of the assets.
The Court also rejected the argument that Mirant was merely a service contractor. A BOT proponent constructs, finances, operates, and manages the facility for a fixed period to recover costs and earn returns before transferring it to the government. That arrangement is different from a simple service contract. Because Mirant was the owner-operator during the cooperation period, NPC could not invoke its own government privileges to defeat the local government’s assessment.
Key Legal Principles Established
The ruling reinforces the BOT Tax Exemption Rule: in real property tax disputes involving public-private partnership assets, the claimant must be the actual entity legally entitled to the exemption or preferential treatment. A government-owned corporation cannot extend its tax privilege to a private entity through contract language.
For exemption under Section 234(c) of the Local Government Code, the machinery and equipment must be actually, directly, and exclusively used by a local water district or government-owned or controlled corporation engaged in water supply or electric power generation and transmission. For special assessment treatment under Section 216, the property must also satisfy the ownership and use requirements imposed by law. The Court emphasized that exemption is the exception, taxation is the rule, and claims for exemption must be supported by the statute and by evidence.
The ruling also confirms that contractual tax assumptions do not bind the taxing authority in the way private parties may hope. A party may agree to shoulder taxes as between itself and its counterparty, but that private allocation does not create a statutory exemption from local real property tax.
What This Means for Businesses and Individuals
Businesses entering BOT, PPP, lease, energy, infrastructure, or concession arrangements should not assume that a government counterparty’s tax status will protect project assets from local real property tax. If a private entity owns, operates, possesses, or beneficially uses the assets, local assessors may treat that private entity as the taxable party or reject an exemption claim made through the government counterparty.
For local governments, this decision strengthens the legal basis for collecting real property taxes on privately operated infrastructure even when the project serves a public function. For investors and project proponents, the ruling makes tax due diligence critical. Contract provisions allocating real property tax responsibility should be drafted with the understanding that they allocate economic burden between the parties, but do not by themselves establish exemption from assessment.
Facing a Local Tax Assessment? Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Real property tax assessments can create substantial exposure for infrastructure operators, landowners, lessees, and businesses using high-value machinery or improvements. A mistaken reliance on contractual exemptions or government-linked status can lead to tax delinquencies, penalties, and prolonged litigation with local governments.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises clients on Philippine tax litigation, local government assessments, real property tax disputes, and contract structuring for public-private projects. Speak with a Philippine tax lawyer at our Makati office or visit MakatiLawFirm.com for guidance on real property tax assessments and exemption claims.