GOCC subsidiary board members who approve unauthorized benefits for themselves may face COA disallowance, refund liability, and solidary exposure.
Government-owned corporations and their subsidiaries cannot treat director allowances as ordinary internal business expenses simply because the subsidiary was incorporated under the Corporation Code. When public officers sit on the boards of GOCC subsidiaries and approve additional benefits for themselves without the required legal authority, those payments may be disallowed, and the board members may be ordered to return the money solidarily.
Why This Matters for Government Corporations, Subsidiaries, and Tax Compliance Teams
For government financial institutions, GOCC subsidiaries, government-linked foundations, accountants, auditors, and directors, this ruling is a warning that compensation structures must be supported by clear authority. A corporate board resolution is not enough when the law reserves approval of directors’ compensation to stockholders, the by-laws, or applicable government compensation rules.
The case is also significant for tax and compliance professionals because it treats compensation governance, audit disallowance, and public fund accountability as connected issues. Payments described as allowances, bonuses, gifts, or incentives may still be illegal disbursements if the recipient is a public officer, the source is a GOCC subsidiary, and the payment lacks statutory or corporate authority.
Background: Land Bank Officers Serving in Subsidiary Boards
Land Bank of the Philippines was the parent government financial institution. Several entities, including Land Bank Insurance Brokerage, Inc., Land Bank Realty Development Corporation, LBP Leasing Corporation, Masaganang Sakahan, Inc., and LBP Countryside Development Foundation, Inc., were its subsidiaries or related foundation. In the course of audit, the Commission on Audit noted that certain Land Bank officers or employees also served as board members or corporate officers of these subsidiaries.
For those additional roles, the subsidiaries paid benefits and allowances such as anniversary bonuses, mid-year gift packages, year-end gift packages, Christmas gift or raffle packages, productivity incentives, and commutable allowances. COA issued a notice of disallowance covering payments amounting to P5,133,830.02, finding that the grants lacked legal basis and violated rules on compensation of directors and public officers. The Supreme Court reviewed the case in Land Bank of the Philippines v. Commission on Audit (G.R. No. 213409).
The Doctrine: A Board Cannot Vote Itself Into Extra Compensation
The central doctrine is simple but powerful: a corporate board cannot substitute its own resolution for the stockholder approval required by law when the matter is the directors’ own compensation. The Court held that even if the subsidiary was wholly owned by the parent corporation, and even if the subsidiary’s board was composed of representatives connected with that parent, the board’s approval was not the same as stockholder approval.
Under Section 30 of the old Corporation Code, directors generally do not receive compensation as directors, except reasonable per diems, unless the by-laws provide otherwise or the stockholders representing at least a majority of the outstanding capital stock approve the compensation. The Court emphasized the distinction between the board and the stockholders. The board manages corporate affairs, but the stockholders own the corporation and retain certain powers reserved to them by law.
This distinction matters because director compensation presents an obvious conflict of interest. If directors could freely vote to grant themselves additional allowances and benefits, the statutory safeguard would become meaningless. The Court therefore characterized the subsidiary board resolutions as ultra vires, or beyond the powers of the board.
COA Jurisdiction Reaches GOCC Subsidiaries
The petitioners argued that the subsidiaries were incorporated under the Corporation Code and that their payments were not government funds. The Court rejected that argument. The Constitution extends COA authority to government-owned or controlled corporations and their subsidiaries. The legal form of incorporation did not remove the entities from COA’s audit jurisdiction.
The Court also treated the payments as impressed with public accountability because they were received by Land Bank officers, who were public officers. Under government auditing principles, money and property officially received by a public officer in any capacity must be accounted for as government funds and government property, unless otherwise provided by law or competent authority.
No Automatic Due Process Violation Without an Audit Observation Memorandum
The Court also clarified that an Audit Observation Memorandum is not mandatory in every disallowance proceeding. Due process requires fair notice and an opportunity to be heard, but audit findings may be communicated through other proper audit documents, including reports, notices of disallowance, orders, or decisions.
In this case, the disallowance was based on Land Bank’s annual audit report. The affected parties were able to respond to the audit findings, explain their position, and appeal to the COA Proper. The notice of disallowance also identified the factual and legal bases for the disallowance, including the Corporation Code, the Constitution, executive compensation rules, and DBM-related issuances. For the Court, those circumstances satisfied due process.
Why the Payments Were Disallowed
The Court found that the additional allowances and benefits lacked legal basis. The subsidiaries’ by-laws did not authorize the grants. The required stockholder approval was not obtained. The board resolutions approving the benefits were invalid because the same directors were effectively approving additional compensation for themselves.
The Court also held that the payments violated Memorandum Order No. 20, Series of 2001, which suspended salary increases and new or increased benefits not aligned with the Salary Standardization Law for senior GOCC officers, including members of boards of directors or trustees, unless executive approval was obtained. Although the Court recognized that reliance on DBM Circular Letter No. 2003-10 was misplaced for payments made before that circular took effect, Memorandum Order No. 20 was already applicable.
Good Faith Did Not Save the Board Members From Refund
The most consequential part of the ruling concerns liability. The Court held that the payees who received the disallowed allowances and benefits must return the amounts they individually received. More importantly, the board members who approved the illegal benefits were also held solidarily liable for the total disallowance as erring approving officers.
The Court refused to accept good faith as a defense for the board members. They were not merely passive recipients of benefits granted by someone else. They participated directly in the approval of the board resolutions that gave them additional compensation. The Court stressed that this involved a patent conflict of interest and an ultra vires act.
However, the Court treated differently the accountants, treasurers, cashiers, general managers, and other approving or certifying officers who processed the payments but did not receive the benefits. In the absence of proof of bad faith, malice, or gross negligence, they were relieved from civil liability, without prejudice to possible administrative or criminal action if warranted.
Practical Takeaways for GOCCs, Subsidiaries, and Corporate Tax Advisers
First, compensation paid to directors of GOCC subsidiaries must be reviewed not only as an accounting item but as a legal authority issue. A payment can be fully documented, internally approved, and booked as an expense, yet still be disallowed if the approving body had no power to authorize it.
Second, parent-subsidiary control does not erase corporate formalities. Even where a parent company wholly owns a subsidiary, the subsidiary’s board is not automatically the stockholder for purposes of approving director compensation. Proper stockholder action, by-law authority, and government compensation approvals must be separately established.
Third, directors and public officers should be careful when approving benefits that they will personally receive. The ruling shows that participation in a self-benefiting approval can convert a recipient into an erring approving officer, with exposure to solidary liability for the full disallowed amount.
Fourth, tax and compliance teams should not look at allowances, bonuses, incentives, and director fees only from the perspective of deductibility, withholding, or payroll treatment. For GOCCs and subsidiaries, the prior question is whether the payment is legally authorized at all. If the payment is unauthorized, tax compliance on the payment will not cure the underlying audit exposure.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises corporations, officers, directors, government-linked entities, and private parties dealing with COA, tax, compensation, and corporate governance issues. For GOCC subsidiaries, regulated corporations, and companies with public-sector exposure, the firm can review board compensation, allowances, director fees, audit disallowances, and related tax compliance risks before they become litigation problems.
For assistance with COA disallowances, corporate governance disputes, director liability, public fund accountability, or tax-sensitive compensation structures, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco.