The CTA partially granted Intercrew’s petition, cancelling portions of the 2015 income tax and EWT assessment due to BIR’s disregard of taxpayer defenses, upholding only unchallenged amounts.
Businesses operating as local manning agencies must carefully track income and account for all tax obligations, as failure to clearly document revenues or expenses can result in partial liabilities. Taxpayers challenging assessments should ensure that the Bureau of Internal Revenue fully considers their explanations; otherwise, portions of the assessment may be voided for due process violations.
Background
Intercrew Philippines Agency, Inc., a domestic manning agency for Dynacom Tankers Management Ltd., faced a deficiency assessment for income tax and expanded withholding tax (EWT) totaling PHP 20,488,283.83 for taxable year 2015 (CTA Case No. 10509). The BIR issued a Preliminary Assessment Notice (PAN), a Formal Letter of Demand (FLD), and a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment (FDDA) after an audit found undeclared revenues and unaccounted rentals. Intercrew protested these findings, arguing that its revenues were fully accounted for and reflected in its Audited Financial Statements, but the BIR maintained the assessment without substantive response.
CTA Ruling
The Court of Tax Appeals found that a portion of the assessment violated Intercrew’s right to administrative due process. Specifically, the FLD reiterated the same deficiencies as the PAN without addressing Intercrew’s defenses or clarifying the legal and factual bases. This disregard constitutes a violation of Section 228 of the Tax Code and implementing regulations (RR Nos. 12-99, 18-2013, 7-2018), which require the taxpayer to be informed of the facts and law underlying the assessment and for the taxpayer’s evidence to be considered. Consequently, the assessment relating to undeclared revenues of PHP 38,582,622.00 and unaccounted rentals of PHP 437,745.45 was declared void.
Key Legal Principles Applied
The CTA emphasized that due process in tax assessment is substantive, not merely formal. A deficiency assessment must provide a written statement of the facts, law, and evidence relied upon, and the taxpayer’s explanations must be considered. Failure to do so renders the assessment void. The Court applied jurisprudence from Ang Tibay v. Court of Industrial Relations and Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Avon Products Manufacturing, Inc., which hold that disregarding a taxpayer’s evidence and defenses undermines the right to know and meet the case against them.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers
Taxpayers should meticulously document income and expenses and ensure all communications with the BIR are detailed and timely. If the BIR issues assessments that ignore the taxpayer’s submissions, these portions of the assessment may be challenged and potentially voided. However, portions not protested or related to disallowed expenses due to non-withholding remain enforceable. In this case, Intercrew remains liable for PHP 111,888.88 covering disallowed expense adjustments and related EWT, including surcharges and interest, while the challenged portions of undeclared revenues and unaccounted rentals were cancelled.
Conclusion
The CTA partially granted Intercrew’s petition, highlighting the critical importance of procedural due process in tax assessments. Businesses and tax practitioners should ensure that any protest is fully substantiated and that the BIR addresses all arguments; failure to consider taxpayer submissions can result in cancellation of assessed taxes. Careful review of FLDs, PANs, and FDDAs is essential to protect taxpayer rights.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Our tax litigation team assists clients in challenging deficient assessments, ensuring proper due process, and representing taxpayers in administrative and judicial proceedings before the BIR and Court of Tax Appeals. Visit