Mining Tax Refund Claims Need DENR-Approved Pre-Operating Expense Proof

Mining taxpayers must prove DENR-approved recoverable pre-operating expenses; audited financial statements alone failed to support the DST refund claim. Mining companies seeking a refund or tax credit for documentary stamp tax cannot rely on audited financial statements alone to prove that they remain within the recovery period under mining regulations. Where the taxpayer’s entitlement depends […]

VAT Refunds Can Fail Even When Export Services Are Zero-Rated

Export service providers may lose VAT refund claims if official receipts fail to state the nature of services, even when the sales are zero-rated. VAT zero-rating is not enough to win a refund or tax credit. Export service providers must ensure that their official receipts state the nature of the services rendered, because a receipt […]

BIR Cannot Revive a Prescribed Capital Gains Tax Assessment Through Internal Case Handling Lapses

The tax court denied the BIR’s bid to revive a prescribed CGT assessment, holding that internal lawyer reassignment was not excusable negligence. Taxpayers facing old capital gains tax assessments gain an important procedural protection from this ruling: once the government’s right to assess has prescribed and the judgment cancelling the assessment has become final, the […]

Missed 180+30-Day Assessment Appeal Deadline Leaves Taxpayer Waiting for CIR Decision

A taxpayer’s petition was dismissed because an FDDA reconsideration request did not create a new 180+30-day appeal period for court review. Taxpayers disputing BIR assessments cannot treat every pending administrative request as a fresh opportunity to go to court. When the 180+30-day period for elevating an assessment protest has already lapsed, filing a petition while […]

Void BIR Assessments Cannot Become Final Despite Protest Defects

A void BIR assessment for denial of due process cannot become final merely because of protest defects, preserving taxpayer defenses in assessment disputes. Taxpayers facing deficiency tax assessments should not assume that a missed or defective protest automatically ends the case when the assessment itself is void for denial of due process. The ruling is […]

VAT Refund Claimants Can Still Prove Their Case in Court After BIR Denial

A VAT refund denial by the BIR may still be challenged in court, where taxpayers can present evidence and prove entitlement through trial de novo. Businesses seeking a refund or tax credit of unutilized input VAT should not assume that a BIR denial ends the case, but they must be prepared to prove every element […]

Taxpayers Challenging BIR Assessments Must Prove LOA and Notice Defects, Tax Court Says

The tax court denied reconsideration, holding that taxpayers must prove alleged LOA and notice defects to defeat BIR assessment regularity. Taxpayers who seek to cancel BIR deficiency tax assessments on due process grounds must present concrete proof that the Letter of Authority or assessment notices were invalidly served; bare allegations, uncertain testimony, and recycled reconsideration […]

Generic Objections Will Not Undo a Tax Refund Win in the Court of Tax Appeals

A refund taxpayer kept its partial CTA win after the Commissioner raised only general objections and failed to identify specific documentary defects. Taxpayers defending a favorable tax refund or tax credit ruling should be prepared to meet a motion for reconsideration, but the government cannot overturn a refund award through broad objections alone. Where the […]

BIR Assessment Voided for Lack of Due Date and Failure to Consider Taxpayer’s PAN Reply

A BIR assessment was voided because the FAN lacked a due date and the BIR failed to genuinely address the taxpayer’s PAN reply. Taxpayers facing BIR deficiency tax assessments should carefully check whether the Final Assessment Notice actually demands payment within a specific period and whether the BIR genuinely addressed their reply to the Preliminary […]

Late Petition for Relief Leaves Tax Refund Judgment Final Against the BIR

A late petition for relief failed after the CTA enforced Rule 38’s strict double-period rule, leaving the taxpayer’s refund judgment final. Tax refund and tax credit cases do not remain open indefinitely just because one party later claims internal oversight, missed notice, or meritorious defenses. Once a Court of Tax Appeals judgment becomes final, a […]