The CTA ruled that Fish2Go’s roasted bangus is VAT-exempt and nullified improper BIR notices, emphasizing due process and procedural compliance in VAT assessments.

Taxpayers selling roasted bangus through take-out services are now protected from improper VAT assessments after the Court of Tax Appeals declared related BIR notices null and void. Businesses in similar circumstances must ensure that any deficiency VAT claims are backed by proper surveillance and factual evidence to satisfy due process requirements.

Background

Fish2Go Corporation, a Philippine food retailer operating kiosks and mini-restaurants, challenged the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) over deficiency VAT claims amounting to Php57,314,288.20 for taxable years 2015 through 2019. The dispute arose after respondents issued a 48-hour notice and a 5-day VAT notice following surveillance allegedly conducted at the petitioner’s business premises. Fish2Go contended that its roasted bangus products are VAT-exempt under Section 109 of the National Internal Revenue Code (NIRC) as they are sold in their original state and undergo only simple preparation processes (CTA Case No. 10286)

CTA 2nd Division Decision FISH2…

.

Issues Before the Court

The primary issues were: (i) whether the 48-hour and 5-day VAT notices complied with Revenue Memorandum Order No. 03-2009 and due process requirements, (ii) whether the deficiency VAT computation was valid, and (iii) whether the roasted bangus sold by petitioner is VAT-exempt under Section 109 of the NIRC.

CTA’s Findings and Ruling

The Court ruled in favor of Fish2Go, holding that the BIR surveillance was conducted not at the petitioner’s registered premises but at a different entity, FTG Fish Products, Inc. As a result, all notices and closure orders derived from this surveillance were void due to lack of factual basis and failure to afford the petitioner due process. The Court emphasized that taxes cannot be collected arbitrarily, and deficiency assessments must be supported by a Preliminary Assessment Notice or Formal Letter of Demand, none of which were issued in this case

CTA 2nd Division Decision FISH2…

CTA 2nd Division Decision FISH2…

.

Regarding the VAT-exempt status, the Court confirmed that Fish2Go’s roasted bangus qualifies as a marine food product sold in its original state, undergoing only freezing, roasting, and simple packaging without additives, preservatives, or marinades. This aligns with Section 109(A) of the NIRC and implementing regulations under RR No. 16-2005. Consequently, the sale of roasted bangus on a take-out basis is VAT-exempt. The Court noted that minor additions, such as diced onions or tomatoes, do not negate the exemption

CTA 2nd Division Decision FISH2…

CTA 2nd Division Decision FISH2…

.

Practical Implications

Food retailers must carefully document preparation processes to claim VAT exemptions for original state marine products. BIR notices issued without proper surveillance or factual substantiation may be invalidated. Taxpayers receiving deficiency assessments should verify that a Preliminary Assessment Notice or Final Assessment Notice has been issued and that due process, including factual disclosure, has been observed. The ruling also underscores the need for the BIR to maintain consistency in applying VAT rulings across affiliated entities.

Conclusion

The Court’s decision reinforces that proper due process and factual evidence are essential prerequisites for VAT collection. Businesses selling roasted marine products through take-out services may benefit from Section 109 exemptions if preparation is limited to simple processes. Fish2Go’s case demonstrates that VAT notices issued without correct procedural compliance can be successfully challenged.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Our tax litigation team can review BIR assessments, assist in filing petitions for review, and ensure that your company’s VAT exemptions are properly documented and defended. For tailored advice and representation, visit

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *