Paying a Disputed BIR Surcharge Can End the Fight Over Abatement

Payment of a disputed BIR surcharge led the tax court to treat the abatement dispute as moot, leaving no live controversy to resolve. Taxpayers challenging a BIR surcharge should be careful before paying the disputed amount, because payment may be treated as acquiescence to the assessment and may leave the Court of Tax Appeals with […]

Taxpayers Cannot Restart the 180-Day Appeal Period by Elevating an FDDA to the Commissioner

Administrative appeals from an FDDA do not restart the 180-day period for disputed BIR assessments; late CTA appeals may be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction. Taxpayers disputing BIR assessments must treat the 180-day period under Section 228 of the Tax Code as a single, non-renewable period; elevating an unfavorable FDDA to the Commissioner does not […]

Late Tax Protest Leaves 2018 BIR Assessment Final and Unappealable

A late-filed protest to a BIR Final Assessment Notice made the 2018 deficiency tax assessment final, executory, and beyond CTA review. Taxpayers who receive a Final Assessment Notice cannot rely on the date appearing on a protest letter; they must prove that the protest was actually filed within 30 days from receipt. In this assessment […]

Electric Cooperatives Can Defeat BIR Income Tax Assessments When Audits Lack Proper Authority

NEA-registered electric cooperative defeats BIR income tax assessment due to unauthorized audit participation and permanent income tax exemption under P.D. No. 269. Electric cooperatives registered with the National Electrification Administration have a powerful defense against income tax assessments: the BIR must both respect their permanent income tax exemption under P.D. No. 269 and ensure that […]

BIR Assessments Can Be Voided When the Taxpayer’s PAN Reply Is Ignored

The tax court voided a BIR assessment for failure to address the taxpayer’s PAN reply and ordered a refund of the amount garnished during the case. Taxpayers facing BIR deficiency assessments should carefully compare the Preliminary Assessment Notice, the taxpayer’s reply, and the later Formal Letter of Demand because an assessment may be void if […]

Tax Assessments Can Be Cancelled When the BIR Ignores the Taxpayer’s PAN Reply

The tax court cancelled a BIR assessment and collection warrants after finding that the taxpayer’s PAN reply was ignored, violating due process. Taxpayers facing BIR collection action should not assume that a warrant of distraint, levy, or garnishment is valid merely because a formal assessment has already been issued. When the BIR receives a taxpayer’s […]

Taxpayers Can End Assessment Litigation Through a Court-Approved Compromise Settlement

A taxpayer ended a disputed BIR assessment through a court-approved compromise after proving payment, doubtful validity, and NEB approval. Businesses facing disputed BIR assessments should treat compromise settlement as a serious litigation option when the assessment is arguably doubtful in validity, but they must be ready to prove that the compromise was properly authorized, paid, […]

BIR Garnishment Set Aside After Defective Service of Tax Assessment Notices

The CTA cancelled BIR assessment notices and set aside garnishment after defective substituted service of the PAN and FLD/FAN violated tax due process. Taxpayers facing bank garnishment may still challenge collection when the BIR cannot prove that the Preliminary Assessment Notice and Final Assessment Notice were validly served. For companies under audit, this ruling reinforces […]

BIR Tax Assessments May Be Voided When an Unauthorized Group Supervisor Continues the Audit

A taxpayer won cancellation of a BIR assessment and refund of garnished funds after an unauthorized group supervisor helped continue the audit. Taxpayers facing BIR collection should check whether every revenue officer and group supervisor who conducted the audit was expressly named in a valid Letter of Authority. In this case, the taxpayer succeeded in […]