The Supreme Court allowed enforcement of a dissolved corporation’s CIAC award through stockholders and required proper compensatory and legal interest.

A dissolved corporation does not automatically lose the practical ability to collect a judgment award. When a corporate claim was already pending before dissolution, the courts and the proper tribunal may still allow enforcement for the benefit of stockholders, successors-in-interest, and other persons entitled to the remaining corporate assets. The ruling is especially important for businesses with long-running arbitration or court cases: dissolution may end ordinary business operations, but it does not necessarily erase pending claims, execution rights, or interest that continues to accrue until payment.

Why This Case Matters to Businesses With Old Judgments

Business disputes can outlive the companies that started them. Construction cases, collection suits, arbitral awards, and appeals may take years or even decades before full satisfaction. The practical question is simple but serious: if a corporation wins a money award but later expires or dissolves, who receives the money, who may continue the case, and how should interest be computed?

In William Golangco Construction Corporation v. Philippine Commercial and International Bank, now Banco de Oro Unibank, Inc. (G.R. No. 269981), the Supreme Court addressed those questions in the context of a construction arbitration award that had been litigated for many years. William Golangco Construction Corporation, or WGCC, had been incorporated in 1963 for a 50-year term. It entered into a construction contract with PCIB for the PCIB Tower II extension. After defects appeared in the building finish, the dispute reached the Construction Industry Arbitration Commission, or CIAC. The case eventually involved competing monetary awards, execution proceedings, prior payments, corporate dissolution, the identity of proper recipients, and the correct computation of interest.

The Doctrine: Pending Corporate Claims Survive Dissolution for Purposes of Winding Up

The Court reaffirmed that a corporation whose term has expired cannot continue doing business as usual. However, dissolution does not mean immediate legal extinction for every purpose. Under the Corporation Code, now reflected in the Revised Corporation Code, a dissolved corporation continues for a limited period to settle and close its affairs, dispose of property, distribute assets, and prosecute or defend suits.

More importantly, the Court applied the established principle that suits commenced before the end of the winding-up period may continue even beyond that period when necessary to complete liquidation and protect the interests of stockholders, creditors, or successors-in-interest. The Court relied on the rule that counsel who continued to prosecute and defend the corporation’s interest may be treated, at least for the litigation, as a trustee of the dissolved corporation.

This is the ruling’s most practical teaching: dissolution is not a magic escape hatch against a valid award, and it is not an automatic bar to collecting a corporate claim that was already part of a pending proceeding. The law’s liquidation rules are not meant to destroy assets. They exist to settle them properly.

Who May Act for a Dissolved Corporation?

BDO challenged the petition on procedural grounds, arguing that the verification and certification against forum shopping were defective because they were signed by counsel and by a person claiming to be a stockholder of the dissolved corporation. The Court refused to dismiss the case on that basis.

The Court harmonized procedural rules on verification and certification against forum shopping with corporate law principles. Normally, a corporation acts through its board, and a representative must show authority through a board resolution or secretary’s certificate. But that ordinary rule becomes difficult when the corporation has already dissolved and no functioning board remains. The Court recognized that the law should not require the impossible.

The law firm representing WGCC had been authorized while the corporation still existed. The Court held that the continuing execution of the arbitral award was intrinsically related to the original CIAC case. Thus, counsel’s signature was sufficient. The Court also accepted that a stockholder-recipient of the award had an aligned interest with the other stockholders and successors-in-interest. Applying the doctrine of necessary implication, the Court recognized authority where no other entity could realistically act to protect the dissolved corporation’s remaining claim.

CIAC May Identify the Proper Recipients of the Award

The Court also upheld CIAC’s authority to determine the persons entitled to receive the judgment award. CIAC has original and exclusive jurisdiction over disputes arising from or connected with construction contracts when the parties agreed to arbitration. Its rules also give it broad executory powers to issue orders necessary and related to execution of the award.

For the Court, the authority to execute an award necessarily includes the authority to determine to whom the award should be paid. Because WGCC had already dissolved and its assets and claims had been distributed to its stockholders and successors-in-interest, CIAC could identify the proper recipients and their corresponding shares. This avoided a needless procedural detour that would only delay satisfaction of a long-final award.

The Court also noted that BDO had already made partial payments to several listed stockholders and successors-in-interest. That fact supported the Court’s refusal to disturb CIAC’s determination of the recipients, especially since BDO did not seriously challenge the accuracy of their identities and shares.

Interest on Judgment Awards: Compensatory Interest and Legal Interest Are Different

The Court granted the petition because the computation of interest had to conform to prevailing jurisprudence. It emphasized the distinction between compensatory interest and legal interest. Compensatory interest indemnifies delay in paying a sum of money. Legal interest, under Article 2209 of the Civil Code, applies when an obligation consists of payment of money and there is no contrary stipulation.

Applying Lara’s Gifts & Decors, the Court held that WGCC was entitled to both forms of interest. The remaining principal amount of PHP 8,630,646.46, less partial payments already made by BDO to certain recipients, must earn interest at 12% per annum from June 21, 1996 until June 30, 2013, and 6% per annum from July 1, 2013 until full payment. The total monetary awards, in turn, earn 6% interest per annum from the finality of the new decision until full payment.

This matters because judgment debtors often argue that delay in payment should stop interest, especially when there are complications about recipients, corporate dissolution, or payment logistics. The Court’s ruling shows that once the legal basis for interest exists, courts will carefully distinguish the type of interest, the reckoning period, and the applicable rate instead of simply cutting off accrual because payment became administratively inconvenient.

Practical Lessons for Creditors, Contractors, and Dissolved Corporations

For contractors and construction owners, the case confirms that CIAC awards remain enforceable through the tribunal’s execution powers. If a corporate party dissolves while an award remains unpaid, the parties should promptly document stockholder shares, successors-in-interest, prior payments, waivers, releases, and authority of counsel or representatives.

For banks, developers, employers, and other judgment debtors, the ruling is a warning against assuming that dissolution defeats collection. The safer course is to raise recipient and authority issues promptly, seek tribunal approval where appropriate, and make payment in a way that protects against double liability without resisting valid execution on purely technical grounds.

For stockholders and heirs of dissolved corporations, the decision provides a pathway to enforce old corporate claims when the corporation no longer has an active board. The remedy is not automatic, and proof of entitlement remains essential. But where the claim is part of an existing case and the recipients’ interests are aligned, the Court may relax procedural rules to prevent injustice.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Long-running business disputes often become more complicated at the execution stage than at trial. Issues such as dissolved corporations, successor liability, arbitral award enforcement, interest computation, and authority to receive payment can determine whether a favorable judgment becomes real recovery. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists clients in civil litigation, construction arbitration, corporate disputes, judgment execution, and post-award enforcement. For legal assistance in enforcing or resisting money judgments, arbitral awards, or corporate claims, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *