The CTA affirmed that tax collection deadlines set by waivers of prescription must be strictly followed; COVID-19 extensions or administrative circulars cannot override them.

Taxpayers and large corporations must adhere to the specific deadlines set forth in waivers of the defense of prescription, even in light of administrative circulars or extensions due to events like the COVID-19 pandemic. The Court of Tax Appeals’ recent resolution underscores that failure to comply with these deadlines can render collection efforts invalid.

Background of the Dispute

Alphalnd Balesin Resort Corporation challenged the issuance of a Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue, arguing that the right to collect the assessed taxes had already prescribed. This dispute arose in the context of assessment collection related to the taxpayer’s obligations under the Large Taxpayers Service framework (CTA Case No. 10485).

CTA’s Ruling on Collection Prescription

The Court rejected the Commissioner’s Motion for Partial Reconsideration, emphasizing that the collection period was constrained by the last Waiver of the Defense of Prescription, dated September 16, 2019. The waiver established a firm deadline of July 31, 2020, for the assessment and collection of the taxes in question. The Commissioner’s reliance on the usual three-year prescriptive period or administrative issuances extending the period due to COVID-19 quarantines was deemed inapplicable.

Specifically, the Court held that although the three-year prescriptive period generally begins from the issuance of the assessment, it cannot override the express terms of the waiver that had been executed by the Commissioner. Furthermore, Revenue Memorandum Circulars cited by the Commissioner (RMC Nos. 136-20, 52-21, and 80-21) did not reference waivers of prescription and were thus inapplicable.

Validity of Tax Protest Filing

Alphalnd Balesin Resort also filed a Partial Motion for Reconsideration, claiming its protest against the Formal Letter of Demand was valid despite the CTA’s prior interpretation of RMC Nos. 039-13 and 011-14. The Court dismissed these arguments, stating that (i) alleged doubts about tax law interpretation do not apply when only one reasonable interpretation exists, (ii) the definition of


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *