The CTA First Division ruled that National Reinsurance Corporation is not liable for the assessed deficiency VAT for CY 2016 as excess input VAT offsets output VAT, disallowing the BIR’s assessment.

Taxpayers engaged in reinsurance services should note that excess input VAT carried over from prior years can offset output VAT liabilities without triggering additional VAT, provided there is proper documentation. A recent Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) First Division decision confirms that the mere disallowance of input VAT, when not linked to unreported sales, does not automatically create a new output VAT liability for the same taxable year.

Background

National Reinsurance Corporation of the Philippines (petitioner) challenged a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment (FDDA) issued by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue (CIR) on December 27, 2021. The FDDA assessed petitioner for an alleged VAT deficiency totaling P3,064,531.57 for calendar year 2016. The dispute primarily involved the disallowance of input VAT credits allocable to VAT-exempt transactions and whether these disallowed credits could result in additional VAT liability. Petitioner had filed waivers extending the period of assessment and had paid a portion of the assessed taxes, maintaining that it possessed sufficient input VAT carry-over to cover the output VAT due. The CTA case was docketed as Case No. 10791.

Facts and Procedural History

Petitioner received a Letter of Authority in November 2018 authorizing BIR officers to examine its books for CY 2016. Notices for the presentation of books and a Preliminary Assessment Notice (PAN) were issued, followed by a Final Assessment Notice/Formal Letter of Demand (FAN/FLD). Petitioner argued that its input VAT credits exceeded the output VAT and that any disallowance pertained only to the computation under the VAT apportionment formula applicable to VAT-exempt and VATable transactions. Petitioner filed a Protest and subsequently a Petition for Review before the CTA.

During the proceedings, the petitioner presented multiple witnesses and financial documentation to substantiate that its excess input VAT could offset the output VAT liability and that there were no unreported sales that would justify additional VAT assessment. The BIR presented its own Revenue Officer as witness but did not dispute the available input VAT balances.

CTA Ruling and Legal Principles

The CTA emphasized that under Section 228 of the NIRC and implementing Revenue Regulations, taxpayers are entitled to administrative protest against assessments and must submit supporting documents. An assessment is presumed correct, and the burden of proof is on the taxpayer to prove irregularities. Here, the CTA First Division found that the CIR failed to demonstrate that any portion of petitioner’s input VAT carry-over could not legally offset output VAT for CY 2016. The Court clarified that disallowance of input VAT credits for VAT-exempt transactions does not itself generate a new output VAT liability. Consequently, petitionerโ€™s excess input VAT remained available for credit, and the assessment lacked legal and factual basis.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Importers

Businesses, particularly in insurance or reinsurance, should maintain precise records of input VAT carry-overs and distinguish between VATable and VAT-exempt transactions. Disallowance of input VAT does not automatically trigger a new output VAT liability if the taxpayer can demonstrate sufficient input VAT to cover reported output VAT. Administrative protests with adequate documentary support are crucial in defending against deficiency assessments. Taxpayers should also be aware of waiver mechanisms to extend assessment periods, but any claim must still be substantiated with accounting records.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Our tax litigation team at Ablola, Saribong & Gueco provides comprehensive support for corporate taxpayers facing VAT disputes or BIR assessments. We assist with administrative protests, preparation of supporting documentation, and representation before the CTA to ensure compliance with statutory deadlines and maximization of available tax credits. Visit

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *