VAT refund denied after taxpayer failed to prove a valid intercompany offsetting arrangement and verifiable foreign-currency payment for zero-rated services.
ROHQs, shared service centers, and Philippine entities billing foreign affiliates cannot rely on internal group accounting alone to support a VAT refund claim; they must prove that their zero-rated sales were actually paid in acceptable foreign currency or through a valid, documented offsetting arrangement that the tax court can verify.
Background of the VAT Refund Dispute
The taxpayer was a regional operating headquarters of a foreign group company and was registered as a VAT taxpayer in the Philippines. For the first and second quarters of 2018, it claimed excess and unutilized input VAT attributable to alleged zero-rated sales of services to non-resident foreign corporation affiliates not doing business in the Philippines.
The taxpayer filed amended VAT returns for the first two quarters of 2018 on September 30, 2019. It later filed an administrative VAT refund claim before the BIR-VAT Credit Audit Division on July 12, 2020, seeking a refund of Php3,880,796.01. After the administrative claim was effectively denied, it brought the case to the Court of Tax Appeals. The Division denied the claim, and the taxpayer elevated the case to the En Banc (CTA EB No. 2897).
Why the Refund Claim Was Denied
The central issue was not simply whether the taxpayer rendered services to foreign affiliates. The decisive question was whether the taxpayer proved that the services qualified as zero-rated sales under Section 108(B)(2) of the National Internal Revenue Code, particularly the requirement that payment must be made in acceptable foreign currency and accounted for in accordance with Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas rules.
The taxpayer argued that its foreign-currency payment requirement was satisfied through an intercompany offsetting arrangement. It explained that its head office provided foreign currency funding, which was booked as a loan payable. The taxpayer then allegedly offset receivables from services rendered to foreign affiliates against the group current account or loan balance maintained within the corporate group.
The En Banc was not persuaded. It agreed with the Division that the taxpayer proved foreign currency loans or advances from the head office, but failed to prove that those advances could legally and contractually be offset against receivables due from separate foreign affiliates. The short-term credit facility agreement showed a lender-borrower relationship between the head office and each affiliate. It did not establish a separate offsetting agreement among the affiliates themselves.
Offsetting Can Support Zero-Rating, But It Must Be Properly Proven
The decision is important because the tax court did not reject offsetting arrangements in principle. The court recognized that BIR issuances and rulings have treated offsetting arrangements as an acceptable alternative to actual inward remittance of foreign currency in export sales or zero-rated transactions, provided that the taxpayer submits the required documentary evidence.
However, the court drew a line between a theoretical group accounting mechanism and legally sufficient proof. It emphasized that a parent company and its affiliates are separate juridical entities. A right of set-off involving one entity’s advances and another entity’s obligations cannot be presumed merely because all entities belong to the same corporate group. If affiliates intend to settle service fees through a centralized clearing, netting, or offsetting system, the arrangement must be supported by contracts, confirmations, correspondence, and transaction-level proof showing how the receivables and liabilities were actually offset.
For Philippine taxpayers providing services to non-resident foreign clients, this is a significant warning. A tax refund claim for input VAT attributable to zero-rated sales will be tested not only against invoices and VAT returns, but also against the actual payment trail. Where payment is made through an intercompany open account or offsetting system, the taxpayer must be ready to show both the legal basis for the offsetting and the specific mechanics of each offset transaction.
The Foreign-Language Schedule Also Failed as Evidence
The taxpayer also relied on a schedule of offsetting of receivables to prove the actual details of the transactions. The En Banc sustained the Division’s refusal to give probative value to the schedule because it was predominantly written in a foreign language that the court could not understand. Although the taxpayer argued that only some words were foreign and that the document was still understandable when taken as a whole, the court found that the deficiency had not been adequately cured.
This evidentiary point should not be overlooked. In tax litigation, supporting schedules, foreign bank documents, intercompany ledgers, credit advices, debit advices, and group accounting reports must be understandable to the court. If documents are in a foreign language, taxpayers should provide proper translations and a clear explanation connecting the document entries to invoices, bank statements, contracts, and VAT returns.
Strict Proof Applies to Tax Refund Claims
The En Banc reiterated the settled rule that claims for tax refund are in the nature of tax exemptions. They are construed strictly against the taxpayer, and the evidence supporting the claim must be strictly scrutinized. This means that the taxpayer bears the burden of proving every factual and legal requirement for the refund.
In this case, the taxpayer’s failure to prove a valid affiliate-level offsetting arrangement was fatal. Even assuming that an offsetting arrangement existed, the taxpayer still failed to prove the actual offsetting details in a manner that the court could verify. The petition was denied, and the Division’s denial of the VAT refund claim was affirmed.
Practical Takeaways for Philippine Taxpayers
Businesses claiming VAT refunds on zero-rated sales should review their payment documentation before filing the administrative claim with the BIR. For service exporters, ROHQs, shared service centers, IT service providers, business process outsourcing companies, and Philippine entities rendering services to foreign affiliates, the contract should clearly identify who owes the service fees, who pays them, and how payment is made.
If payment is made through offsetting, taxpayers should maintain a complete documentary trail. This should include the contract authorizing the offsetting, proof of the liability being offset, proof of the receivable from the zero-rated sale, correspondence or confirmations from the entities involved, accounting entries showing the actual offset, and bank or funding documents where relevant. The documentation must show not only that money moved within the group, but that the receivable from the foreign customer was actually settled in a manner acceptable under VAT zero-rating rules.
Taxpayers should also avoid waiting until litigation to fix evidentiary gaps. The refund file submitted to the BIR should already be litigation-ready. Courts will not presume compliance from group practice, internal accounting treatment, or generalized testimony. Every invoice, payment, offset, and supporting document must be capable of being traced and explained.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in VAT refund claims, Court of Tax Appeals litigation, BIR audit disputes, and tax documentation reviews for zero-rated sales and export service transactions. Our tax litigation practice helps clients assess refund viability, organize evidence, prepare administrative claims, respond to BIR denials, and pursue judicial remedies before the Court of Tax Appeals.
For businesses with foreign affiliates, centralized treasury systems, intercompany netting arrangements, or recurring zero-rated service income, early legal review can prevent costly refund denials. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team on VAT refund claims, zero-rated sales documentation, and Court of Tax Appeals representation.