The tax court voided a BIR assessment for failure to address the taxpayer’s PAN reply and ordered a refund of the amount garnished during the case.

Taxpayers facing BIR deficiency assessments should carefully compare the Preliminary Assessment Notice, the taxpayer’s reply, and the later Formal Letter of Demand because an assessment may be void if the BIR simply repeats its findings without explaining why the taxpayer’s defenses were rejected. In a July 2025 decision involving a 2016 tax audit, the Court of Tax Appeals cancelled a multimillion-peso assessment and ordered the refund of a bank-garnished amount after finding that the taxpayer’s right to administrative due process was violated.

Background of the Tax Assessment Dispute

The dispute arose from a BIR audit of a domestic corporation engaged in operating the local stock exchange. The BIR issued a Letter of Authority authorizing revenue officers to examine the taxpayer’s books and accounting records for all internal revenue taxes for taxable year 2016. During the audit, the taxpayer executed several waivers of the defense of prescription, extending the period within which the BIR could assess taxes.

The BIR later issued a Preliminary Assessment Notice assessing the taxpayer for deficiency income tax, value-added tax, expanded withholding tax, final withholding tax, documentary stamp tax, and miscellaneous charges in the aggregate amount of ₱67,687,897.27. The taxpayer replied to the notice and disputed the proposed assessments. The BIR then issued a Formal Letter of Demand and assessment notices for ₱68,567,425.01, and later issued a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment reducing the amount to ₱51,166,891.65 for deficiency income tax, VAT, EWT, FWT, and miscellaneous charges. The Commissioner also pursued collection, resulting in a warrant of distraint and/or levy and the garnishment of ₱51,026,891.65 from the taxpayer’s bank account. The taxpayer elevated the dispute to the tax court (CTA Case No. 10781).

The Court Upheld the Waivers But Still Cancelled the Assessment

One of the taxpayer’s arguments was that the waivers of the defense of prescription were defective, and that the BIR’s right to assess had already prescribed. The Court did not fully agree. It examined the waivers under RMO No. 14-2016 and recognized that the first waiver, although the taxpayer’s own copy did not show acceptance, was valid based on the BIR’s copy showing acceptance by the group supervisor designated in the Letter of Authority. The Court also considered the COVID-19 suspension of prescriptive periods, including the 137-day suspension clarified under BIR issuances, in determining the timeliness of the later waiver and assessment.

This part of the ruling is important because the taxpayer did not win simply by attacking the waivers. The Court treated the waiver issue separately and found that the BIR’s assessment was not defeated on prescription alone. For taxpayers and tax managers, this is a reminder that prescription arguments must be carefully documented, especially where multiple waivers were executed and where the audit period overlapped with pandemic-related suspension rules.

Why the Assessment Was Declared Void

The decisive issue was due process. The taxpayer had filed a detailed response to the Preliminary Assessment Notice, raising explanations and refutations on the proposed deficiency income tax, VAT, EWT, FWT, and DST assessments. However, when the BIR issued the Formal Letter of Demand, the Court found that the attached Details of Discrepancies merely reiterated or copied the earlier findings in the Preliminary Assessment Notice. Only the interest amounts were adjusted.

For the Court, this showed that the BIR did not meaningfully consider the taxpayer’s explanations before issuing the Formal Letter of Demand. The taxpayer was left unaware of how the BIR appreciated, evaluated, or rejected the defenses raised in the reply to the Preliminary Assessment Notice. That failure violated the taxpayer’s right to administrative due process under Section 228 of the National Internal Revenue Code and the implementing rules on tax assessments.

The Court applied the principle that a taxpayer must be fully informed not only of the factual and legal bases of the assessment, but also of the reasons why its explanations or defenses were rejected. A demand letter that merely repeats the same conclusions, without showing the BIR’s evaluation of the taxpayer’s reply, does not satisfy due process. Because the assessment was issued in violation of due process, it was null and void. A void assessment produces no valid legal consequences and cannot be enforced by collection.

Refund of Garnished Taxes Without a Separate Administrative Claim

The ruling also addressed an important collection issue. The Commissioner argued that the Court had no jurisdiction to order the refund of the garnished amount because the taxpayer had not first filed a separate administrative claim for refund. The Court rejected that argument.

The Court reasoned that the case involved a disputed assessment, not an ordinary refund claim filed in the first instance. The garnishment occurred while the assessment case was pending, and the money was released to the BIR because of the challenged assessment. Requiring a separate administrative refund claim would have been a useless formality because the Commissioner had already denied the taxpayer’s protest and pursued collection. It was therefore proper for the Court to resolve the validity of the assessment and the refund of the garnished amount in one proceeding.

As a result, the Court cancelled and set aside the Formal Letter of Demand and assessment notices, reversed and set aside the Final Decision on Disputed Assessment, and ordered the Commissioner to refund ₱51,026,891.65, representing the amount garnished from the taxpayer’s bank account and released to the BIR during the case.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers Under BIR Audit

For CFOs, tax managers, and corporate counsel, the ruling reinforces that a response to a Preliminary Assessment Notice is not a mere formality. It should be detailed, organized, and supported by documents because the BIR is required to consider it. If the later Formal Letter of Demand simply repeats the Preliminary Assessment Notice without addressing the taxpayer’s objections, that omission may support a due process challenge before the Court of Tax Appeals.

The case also shows why businesses must preserve the full assessment trail: Letter of Authority, waivers, Notice for Informal Conference, Preliminary Assessment Notice, reply to the PAN, Formal Letter of Demand, protest, supplemental protest, Final Decision on Disputed Assessment, warrants, bank notices, and proof of collection. In assessment litigation, the chronology often matters as much as the substantive tax issues.

Taxpayers should also treat garnishment and distraint as urgent litigation events. Even if collection has already occurred, the taxpayer may still pursue relief in the pending assessment case where the collection arose directly from the disputed assessment. The ruling confirms that a taxpayer should not be forced into duplicative proceedings when the central question is whether the BIR had a valid assessment to collect in the first place.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, business owners, executives, and individuals in BIR audits, assessment protests, collection disputes, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can review Preliminary Assessment Notices, draft protest submissions, evaluate prescription and due process defenses, respond to warrants of distraint, levy, or garnishment, and represent taxpayers in proceedings before the Court of Tax Appeals.

If your company has received a BIR assessment, Formal Letter of Demand, Final Decision on Disputed Assessment, or collection notice, early legal review can determine whether the assessment is enforceable or vulnerable to cancellation. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *