CTA upholds UCHC refund of local business taxes after Taguig City applied presumptive income method without ordinance or public hearings, confirming taxpayer rights.

Local business taxpayers now have a clear path to challenge assessments based on arbitrary presumptive income levels. The Court of Tax Appeals recently affirmed the refund claim of Union Cement Holdings Corporation (UCHC) after Taguig City imposed local business tax (LBT) using a presumptive income method not formally adopted in local ordinance or subjected to public hearings. Taxpayers who pay taxes under an improper assessment may be entitled to full refunds if procedural requirements are ignored.

Background

The City of Taguig, through its City Treasurer, assessed UCHC for the first quarter of 2011 LBT amounting to Php400,418.86, calculated using a Presumptive Income Level Assessment Approach (PILAA) based on UCHC’s 2009 gross receipts rather than the 2010 taxable year. UCHC paid under protest and filed for a refund after the City Treasurer failed to act on its protest (CTA AC No. 313). The Regional Trial Court, Branch 271, Taguig City, granted UCHC’s claim, ordering the refund of Php494,715.68, including interest. The City appealed, but the CTA affirmed the refund.

CTA Ruling

The CTA emphasized that a local government unit may only employ PILAA if two requisites are satisfied: the PILAA must be authorized in the local tax ordinance and subject to public hearings, and it can only be used when the taxpayer cannot provide proof of gross receipts. In this case, Taguig City failed to demonstrate that PILAA was adopted in the local ordinance or that public hearings were conducted. Furthermore, UCHC had submitted its sworn gross receipts for 2010, negating the need to apply a presumptive income standard.

The Court also underscored that even when PILAA is properly adopted, local authorities must first require taxpayers to declare their actual gross sales, verify such declarations through a Letter of Authority, and only then apply presumptive income if taxpayers fail to provide or validate records. Taguig City bypassed these procedural safeguards, resulting in an invalid assessment.

Key Legal Principles

Section 82(d) of the Taguig City Revenue Code allows verification under


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *