A late VAT refund appeal was dismissed despite a large input tax claim, reaffirming that BIR inaction after 90 days can trigger the 30-day CTA deadline.

VAT-registered exporters and zero-rated sellers must closely monitor the 90-day BIR action period and the 30-day appeal window because a late judicial claim can result in dismissal even when the refund amount is substantial and even when the BIR later issues a partial denial notice. For taxpayers pursuing input VAT refunds or tax credit certificates, the ruling reinforces that timing is not a mere technicality; it is jurisdictional.

Background of the VAT Refund Dispute

The taxpayer, a domestic corporation, filed an administrative application for tax credits or refund before the BIR on July 15, 2020 in the amount of Php87,865,477.31. The claim involved unutilized excess input VAT attributable to the taxpayer’s zero-rated or effectively zero-rated sales for the first to fourth quarters of taxable year 2018.

On October 21, 2020, the taxpayer received a VAT Refund Notice dated October 2, 2020 from the BIR VAT Credit and Audit Division. The BIR approved part of the refund claim in the amount of Php28,739,024.78, but denied the balance of Php59,126,452.53. The taxpayer then filed a Petition for Review before the Court in Division on November 20, 2020. The Division dismissed the petition for lack of jurisdiction, and the taxpayer elevated the matter to the Court En Banc (CTA EB No. 3025).

The Core Issue: When Should the 30-Day Appeal Period Be Counted?

The dispute centered on Section 112 of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended by the TRAIN Law, and its interaction with the law governing the jurisdiction of the Court of Tax Appeals. Under the applicable version of Section 112, the Commissioner had 90 days from submission of the supporting documents to act on a claim for refund of creditable input taxes. If the claim was fully or partially denied, the taxpayer could appeal to the Court of Tax Appeals within 30 days from receipt of the decision denying the claim.

The taxpayer argued that the TRAIN Law changed the prior rule. It maintained that, after the amendment, a taxpayer could appeal only from an actual decision of the Commissioner denying the refund claim, and that the law no longer gave the taxpayer a remedy to appeal from the Commissioner’s inaction after the 90-day period. On that theory, the taxpayer treated the 30-day appeal period as running from its October 21, 2020 receipt of the VAT Refund Notice.

The Commissioner disagreed. The Commissioner’s position, which the majority ultimately sustained, was that the Court of Tax Appeals still had jurisdiction over both decisions and inaction of the Commissioner in refund cases, and that inaction within the statutory period is deemed a denial for purposes of judicial appeal.

The En Banc Majority Sustained the Dismissal for Lack of Jurisdiction

The Court En Banc first held that the taxpayer’s appeal from the Division to the En Banc was timely. The Division denied reconsideration on October 8, 2024; the taxpayer received the resolution on October 29, 2024; and it filed its En Banc petition on November 13, 2024, within the 15-day period under the Revised Rules of the Court of Tax Appeals.

However, on the merits, the En Banc majority held that the original judicial claim before the Division was filed out of time. The taxpayer’s administrative claim was filed on July 15, 2020. The Commissioner’s 90-day period to act expired on October 13, 2020. From that date, the taxpayer had 30 days, or until November 12, 2020, to file its judicial claim. Because the taxpayer filed the Petition for Review only on November 20, 2020, the filing was eight days late.

The Court therefore affirmed the Division’s dismissal for lack of jurisdiction. The taxpayer’s substantive claim for the remaining Php59,126,452.53 in input VAT refund was not granted because the Court could not proceed to the merits once the judicial claim was found to have been filed beyond the jurisdictional deadline.

Why the Later BIR Refund Notice Did Not Save the Petition

A critical point in the ruling is that the BIR VAT Refund Notice, although received by the taxpayer on October 21, 2020, was treated as having been issued beyond the 90-day period. For purposes of reckoning the 30-day period to appeal, the Court treated the Commissioner’s failure to act within the 90-day period as a deemed denial by operation of law.

The majority read Section 112 of the Tax Code together with Republic Act No. 1125, as amended by Republic Act No. 9282, the special law defining the jurisdiction of the Court of Tax Appeals. Under that jurisdictional statute, the Court of Tax Appeals may review both decisions and inaction of the Commissioner in cases involving refunds of internal revenue taxes, where the law provides a specific period for action. In such cases, the Commissioner’s inaction is deemed a denial.

The Court also applied the principle that special laws prevail over general laws. It found no express legislative intent in the TRAIN Law to amend or repeal the jurisdictional provisions allowing appeals from the Commissioner’s inaction. For the majority, reading the TRAIN Law as removing any judicial remedy for inaction would leave taxpayers waiting indefinitely for a BIR decision, a result the Court considered inconsistent with the protection of both government and taxpayer interests.

The Dissent Shows That the Issue Remains Legally Significant

The case was not unanimous. The dissenting opinions took the view that the TRAIN Law’s deletion of the prior statutory language referring to the Commissioner’s failure to act and the expiration of the 120-day period should be given effect. Under that interpretation, during the TRAIN Law period, a taxpayer could appeal only from an actual denial decision, not from deemed denial through inaction.

The dissent further noted that the Ease of Paying Taxes Act later reinserted language referring to the Commissioner’s failure to act and the expiration of the 90-day period. For the dissent, that later reinsertion supported the view that the TRAIN Law had temporarily removed the deemed-denial appeal route for input VAT refund claims.

For taxpayers, this split matters. Although the majority decision controls the outcome of the case, the dissent highlights the continuing interpretive difficulty created by successive amendments to Section 112. Taxpayers handling VAT refund claims covering transition periods should therefore proceed conservatively and protect every possible deadline.

Practical Takeaways for VAT Refund Claimants

First, taxpayers should not assume that an actual BIR denial received after the 90-day period automatically restarts or extends the judicial appeal period. Under the majority’s approach, the safer position is to treat BIR inaction after the 90-day period as a denial that immediately triggers the 30-day period to file with the Court of Tax Appeals.

Second, taxpayers should prepare the judicial claim while the administrative claim is still pending. Waiting for the BIR to issue a written notice can be dangerous if the statutory action period has already lapsed. In VAT refund cases, a few days of delay can result in loss of jurisdiction and dismissal of an otherwise potentially valid refund claim.

Third, exporters and companies with zero-rated sales should maintain a deadline matrix for each taxable quarter, including the close of the quarter, the two-year administrative filing deadline, the date of actual administrative filing, the end of the 90-day BIR action period, and the final day to appeal to the Court of Tax Appeals. This is especially important for high-value refund claims involving tens of millions of pesos.

Fourth, the ruling reinforces that input VAT refund litigation is both documentary and procedural. A taxpayer may believe that it has complied with VAT registration, zero-rated sales, invoicing, foreign currency remittance, and non-application requirements, but those points will not matter if the petition is filed beyond the jurisdictional period.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, exporters, importers, and corporate groups in managing tax refund claims, disputed assessments, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can help evaluate administrative refund filings, compute jurisdictional deadlines, prepare petitions for review, organize supporting VAT documentation, and develop litigation strategy where the BIR denies or fails to act on a claim.

For businesses facing a denied VAT refund, an expiring appeal period, or uncertainty over when to elevate a tax dispute to the Court of Tax Appeals, early legal review is essential. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team and protect your remedies before procedural deadlines close.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *