Renewable energy VAT refund claims must separate hydropower sales from ancillary services; only valid zero-rated sales supported the partial refund.

Renewable energy companies claiming VAT refunds must separate true sales of power or fuel generated from renewable sources from related services, because only the former may qualify for zero-rating. In this ruling, the taxpayer recovered part of its unutilized input VAT, but the Court reduced the claim after excluding ancillary service revenues from the taxpayer’s valid zero-rated sales base.

Background of the VAT Refund Dispute

The taxpayer is a VAT-registered power generation company operating a hydroelectric power plant in Pangasinan. For the period April 1, 2020 to March 31, 2021, it sought a refund or tax credit for excess and unutilized input VAT allegedly attributable to zero-rated sales. The administrative claim was filed with the BIR on June 27, 2022, and the BIR later denied the claim for lack of legal basis and alleged failure to comply with Section 112(A) of the National Internal Revenue Code.

The taxpayer elevated the dispute to the tax court after receiving the denial. In the background of the case, the claim originally involved ₱30,149,602.19, although the taxpayer later relied on the lower amount recommended by the independent certified public accountant. The case was decided by the Special Second Division of the Court of Tax Appeals (Case No. 11012).

The Core Issue: Which Sales Were Validly Zero-Rated?

The key issue was whether the taxpayer was entitled to a refund or tax credit for unutilized input VAT for the relevant fiscal year. The taxpayer argued that its sales were zero-rated because they arose from power generated through hydropower, a renewable energy source. It had sold power to the National Power Corporation and had also sold ancillary service capacity or reserve power to the National Grid Corporation of the Philippines.

The Court accepted the taxpayer’s position only in part. It held that the sale of power or fuel generated through renewable sources of energy, including hydropower, is subject to zero percent VAT under Section 108(B)(7) of the Tax Code. However, the Court drew a strict line between the sale of renewable power itself and the sale of ancillary services. Even if the ancillary services were sourced from the hydroelectric power plant, the Court held that the VAT zero-rating applies strictly to the sale of power or fuel generated through renewable sources and does not extend to related services.

Ancillary Services Were Treated as Subject to 12% VAT

The ruling is important for generation companies because the Court treated ancillary services as outside the scope of the renewable energy zero-rating provision. The Court noted that revenue regulations expressly limit zero-rating to the sale of power or fuel generated through renewable sources and do not extend the benefit to services related to the maintenance or operation of plants generating such power.

The Court also relied on the general VAT rule on sale of services. Under Section 108(A) of the Tax Code, VAT applies to all kinds of services performed in the Philippines for a fee, remuneration, or consideration. The Court further noted that regulations on electricity sales include amounts charged by generation companies for the sale of electricity and related ancillary services in gross receipts subject to VAT. On that basis, the taxpayer’s sales to the grid operator for ancillary services were not accepted as valid zero-rated sales.

Timeliness and VAT Registration Were Satisfied

The taxpayer succeeded on the procedural requirements. The Court found that the administrative claim was timely filed within two years from the close of the taxable quarters when the relevant sales were made. The judicial claim was also timely filed within thirty days from receipt of the BIR’s denial. The taxpayer was likewise shown to be a VAT-registered entity.

The Court also found that the foreign currency accounting requirement did not apply because the taxpayer’s zero-rated sales were based on Section 108(B)(7), not the provisions requiring proof that acceptable foreign currency exchange proceeds had been duly accounted for under Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas rules.

Why the Refund Was Reduced

The taxpayer reported total sales of ₱2,404,750,155.44 for the fiscal year, including reported zero-rated sales of ₱2,398,637,008.42. However, the Court found that the reported zero-rated sales included two categories: power generation and supply to the National Power Corporation amounting to ₱2,212,629,752.44, and ancillary services to the National Grid Corporation of the Philippines amounting to ₱186,007,254.75. Only the sales to the National Power Corporation were accepted as valid zero-rated sales.

The Court also reviewed the input VAT substantiation. Not all claimed input VAT was accepted. The Court found valid input VAT of ₱21,970,983.18. After allocating input VAT between vatable sales and zero-rated sales, and after computing the portion attributable only to valid zero-rated sales, the Court arrived at a refundable amount of ₱19,245,042.50.

The Court Did Not Use the Refund Case to Make a Deficiency VAT Assessment

A notable point in the ruling is the Court’s treatment of the disallowed ancillary service revenues. Although the Court held that the ancillary services did not qualify for zero-rating, it did not use the refund case to impose or compute a deficiency VAT assessment on those revenues. The Court cited the principle that, in a Section 112 VAT refund case, the tax court determines the unutilized or unused input tax attributable to zero-rated sales. It does not exercise assessment powers or allow a refund case to become a vehicle for assessing deficiency VAT.

This distinction matters for taxpayers. A refund case may reduce the allowable refund if certain sales are not validly zero-rated, but that does not automatically mean the Court will assess deficiency VAT in the same proceeding. Assessment remains within the authority of the Commissioner, subject to the rules on tax assessments and prescription.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Power Companies

For renewable energy companies, the most important takeaway is that zero-rating must be transaction-specific. It is not enough that the taxpayer operates a renewable energy facility. The taxpayer must prove that the particular sale is a sale of power or fuel generated through renewable sources, not merely a related service, capacity arrangement, reserve service, or ancillary service.

For CFOs and tax managers, this ruling underscores the need to classify revenues carefully before filing a VAT refund claim. Sales invoices, official receipts, contracts, statements of account, and accounting schedules should clearly identify which transactions are renewable power sales and which are other service revenues. A broad treatment of all renewable-energy-related income as zero-rated may expose the refund claim to partial denial.

For refund claimants generally, the decision also confirms that strict substantiation remains central in VAT refund litigation. The taxpayer must prove timeliness, VAT registration, the existence of valid zero-rated sales, the payment or incurrence of input VAT, the attribution of input VAT to zero-rated sales, and non-application of the same input VAT against output tax or carry-over in succeeding periods. Failure to prove any required element may reduce or defeat the claim.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, power companies, and corporate groups in preparing, defending, and litigating VAT refund claims before the BIR and the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can help review refund documentation, classify zero-rated and vatable transactions, prepare evidentiary schedules, assess litigation risks, and represent taxpayers in disputes involving VAT refunds, tax credit certificates, and BIR denials.

For assistance with a pending VAT refund, tax assessment, customs dispute, or Court of Tax Appeals case, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *