Importers must exhaust BOC remedies before CTA review. The Court upheld abandonment of rice shipments after missed customs appeal deadlines.
Importers facing abandonment, forfeiture, or auction of shipments cannot treat the Court of Tax Appeals as the first stop after an adverse customs action. When customs rules provide an administrative appeal route, the importer must follow that route on time; otherwise, the challenged order may become final, and the CTA will have no jurisdiction to revive the dispute.
The Doctrine: Final Customs Orders Require Timely Administrative Appeal
The ruling establishes a practical customs litigation doctrine: a customs abandonment order confirmed by the Commissioner does not automatically become reviewable by the CTA if the importer failed to exhaust the administrative remedy specifically available under customs regulations. The importer must timely appeal within the administrative framework, especially where the governing Customs Memorandum Order provides a 15-day period and requires the appeal to raise new or specific arguments.
For importers, customs brokers, and companies handling regulated goods, the most consequential point is not merely procedural. A missed administrative deadline can result in the loss of the shipment itself. Even where the importer believes it already made an advance payment, or insists that the Bureau of Customs should not have declared the goods abandoned, the courts may refuse to reach the merits if the proper customs appeal was not timely pursued.
Background: Rice Imports, Advance Payments, and Decrees of Abandonment
Victor R. Del Rosario Rice Mill Corporation imported rice under the 2017-2018 Minimum Access Volume Rice Importation Program of the National Food Authority. As part of the import permit process, the company made advance payments for customs duties and taxes through debit advice arrangements with LandBank, with amounts applied and remitted through the Bureau of Treasury. Import permits were issued for rice shipments between February and September 2018, and import entries were later filed.
The Bureau of Customs later treated the shipments as assessed but unpaid. The Manila International Container Port sent a notice to pay by electronic mail, warning that the goods could be deemed abandoned if duties and taxes remained unpaid. The importer denied receiving the email. Decrees of abandonment were issued, and the importer filed letters and motions seeking to lift or recall those decrees. The District Collector affirmed the abandonment, and the Commissioner later issued a consolidated order affirming the action. The importer eventually went to the CTA, but the case reached the Supreme Court after the CTA dismissed the petition for lack of jurisdiction (G.R. No. 278819).
Why the CTA Had No Jurisdiction
The Supreme Court denied the importer’s petition and affirmed the CTA En Banc. The core reason was exhaustion of administrative remedies. Although the CTA has exclusive appellate jurisdiction over decisions of the Commissioner of Customs involving customs duties, seizure, detention, release of property, forfeitures, penalties, and other customs matters, that jurisdiction is appellate in nature. The taxpayer or importer must first complete the remedy that customs law and customs issuances require before judicial review can be triggered.
The Court relied on the structure of Republic Act No. 1125, as amended by Republic Act No. 9282, and Customs Memorandum Order No. 17-2019. Under the customs order cited by the Court, a decision of the District Collector confirmed by the Office of the Commissioner becomes final and executory within 15 days from the importer’s receipt unless appealed to the Commissioner in the required manner. That appeal must set forth new or specific arguments, or matters that were overlooked or not treated in the appealed decision.
Del Rosario Rice Mill received the April 1, 2019 consolidated order on May 3, 2019. The Supreme Court agreed with the CTA that the importer should have pursued the administrative appeal within the 15-day period. Instead, it filed its petition with the CTA on May 21, 2019. By then, the relevant customs action had become final and executory for purposes of the remedy structure. The later approval for auction did not suspend or restart the period for exhausting administrative remedies.
Due Process Was Satisfied by Electronic Notice
The importer argued that its right to due process was violated because it supposedly did not receive the notice to pay. The Court was not persuaded. It held that the notice sent through electronic mail substantially complied with the due notice requirement under the applicable customs rules and Section 1129(c) of the Customs Modernization and Tariff Act.
The Court gave weight to the fact that Del Rosario Rice Mill was a regular and veteran importer. Because it was familiar with rice importation procedures, customs documentation, and the payment process, the Court found that it was sufficiently informed at the crucial stages before the matter reached the approval for auction. The ruling also recognized that customs law allows the Bureau of Customs to provide notice through electronic means or personal service.
Advance Payment Is Not Always Actual Payment
The ruling also matters for companies that rely on advance payment mechanisms in regulated import programs. The CTA En Banc had clarified, and the Supreme Court left undisturbed, that the alleged advance payment of customs duties and taxes did not automatically mean actual payment of duties and taxes for the specific shipments. The amounts were treated as earmarked for future payment, with crediting to the BOC account to be processed only upon the issuance of assessment notices.
For businesses, this is a serious compliance lesson. An internal belief that funds have already been advanced or set aside may not protect the shipment if the formal customs payment process has not been completed. Importers should separately monitor assessment, payment application, customs posting, and release requirements rather than assuming that compliance with an import permit prerequisite fully satisfies the duties and taxes due on entry.
When Exceptions to Exhaustion Will Not Save the Case
The Court acknowledged the recognized exceptions to the exhaustion of administrative remedies, including patent illegality, due process violations, urgency of judicial intervention, lack of a plain and adequate remedy, great and irreparable damage, and strong public interest. However, it found none of those exceptions applicable.
The ruling is important because importers often invoke urgency once goods are at risk of auction, spoilage, demurrage, storage charges, or commercial loss. But the Supreme Court’s approach shows that urgency alone is not enough when the party had an available administrative remedy and failed to use it. Courts will look at whether customs procedures gave the importer a plain route to challenge the order, and whether the alleged due process defect is real enough to excuse non-exhaustion.
Practical Impact for Importers and Customs Disputes
For importers, the decision changes the practical risk calculation in customs disputes. The first litigation question is not whether the Bureau of Customs was correct on the merits, but whether the importer preserved the remedy. Once a decree of abandonment or related customs order is issued, counsel must immediately identify the governing customs issuance, the exact appeal period, the office to which the appeal must be made, and the arguments that must be raised administratively.
For tax managers and customs compliance teams, the ruling also underscores the importance of email monitoring. Registered email addresses used for customs transactions should be treated as official legal notice channels. Companies should maintain internal protocols for daily monitoring, escalation to legal and finance teams, and documentation of receipt, transmission, and payment actions.
For businesses with perishable, regulated, or high-value imports, the ruling is a warning against fragmented compliance. Import permits, advance payments, goods declarations, assessment notices, and customs release steps must be tracked as one integrated legal workflow. A missed customs deadline can move the dispute from a recoverable administrative issue to a final loss of legal remedy.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises importers, logistics companies, trading businesses, and regulated enterprises on customs disputes, tax litigation, administrative appeals, and preventive compliance systems. If your company received a notice to pay, decree of abandonment, forfeiture action, seizure notice, or auction-related communication from the Bureau of Customs, early legal action is critical to preserve your remedies.
Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax and litigation team on customs remedies, CTA appeals, import compliance, and urgent strategies to protect shipments from abandonment, forfeiture, or auction.