A criminal tax case was dismissed after the Court found the five-year prescription period had run before the Information was filed.
Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges may invoke prescription where the government files the Information in the Court of Tax Appeals beyond the five-year period under the Tax Code, especially when the alleged failure to pay assessed taxes was already known or readily determinable by the BIR years earlier.
Background of the Criminal Tax Dispute
The case involved a criminal charge for willful failure to pay tax under Section 255 of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended. The taxpayer, a proprietor of a service center registered with a BIR revenue district office in Quezon City, was accused of failing to pay income tax deficiencies for taxable year 2006 amounting to Php 1,465,013.08, exclusive of surcharge and interest.
The prosecution alleged that the taxpayer failed to pay despite a final assessment, prior notices, post notices, and a demand before suit. The Information was filed on April 6, 2018. The Court in Division dismissed the criminal case on the ground that the offense had prescribed, recalled the alias warrant of arrest, and later denied the prosecution’s motion for reconsideration. The government elevated the matter to the Court En Banc (CTA EB Crim. No. 147), arguing that prescription had been interrupted earlier when the criminal complaint was filed before the Department of Justice on January 30, 2014.
The Central Issue: When Is Prescription Interrupted in a Criminal Tax Case?
The sole issue was whether the criminal action had already prescribed when the Information was filed. Under Section 281 of the Tax Code, violations of any provision of the Code prescribe after five years. The provision also states that prescription begins to run from the day of the commission of the violation, or if unknown at the time, from discovery and the institution of judicial proceedings for investigation and punishment.
The government argued that the filing of the complaint before the DOJ for preliminary investigation interrupted the running of prescription. In practical terms, that argument would have saved the criminal tax case because the DOJ referral occurred before the fifth year from the reckoning date found by the Court.
The Court En Banc Affirmed the Dismissal of the Criminal Tax Case
The Court En Banc denied the government’s Petition for Review and affirmed the dismissal of the criminal case. It held that, under the controlling rule applied by the majority, the prescriptive period for criminal tax cases within the jurisdiction of the Court of Tax Appeals is interrupted by the filing of the Information before the Court, not by the earlier filing of a complaint before the DOJ.
The Court noted that the Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notice dated November 26, 2009 was sent to the taxpayer by registered mail on the same date. Although domestic registered mail had an estimated turnaround time of seven working days, the Court in Division liberally assumed receipt 30 days from mailing, or on December 26, 2009. The taxpayer then had 30 days to file a protest. When that period lapsed, the assessment became due and demandable.
On that basis, the five-year prescriptive period began to run on January 26, 2010. The prosecution therefore had until January 26, 2015 to file the Information before the Court. However, the Information was filed only on April 6, 2018. For the majority, the criminal action had already prescribed long before the case reached the Court.
Why the Court Rejected the Government’s DOJ Filing Argument
The Court emphasized that the BIR could not claim that it discovered the alleged criminal violation only when the case was referred to the DOJ in 2014. By the time the taxpayer failed to protest or pay within the required period, the BIR was already aware, or at least could readily verify through its own systems, whether payment had been made or whether a protest had been filed.
The Court also relied on the Revised Rules of the Court of Tax Appeals, which provide that criminal actions before the Court in Division, in the exercise of original jurisdiction, are instituted by the filing of an Information in the name of the People of the Philippines. For criminal actions involving violations of the Tax Code and other laws enforced by the BIR, the Commissioner of Internal Revenue must approve their filing. The rule further provides that the institution of the criminal action interrupts prescription.
Because the special rules governing the Court of Tax Appeals specifically address how criminal tax actions are instituted, the Court found the government’s reliance on the general Rules of Criminal Procedure misplaced. The general rules apply only suppletorily when the tax court’s rules do not specifically govern the matter.
The Effect of the Newer Supreme Court Pronouncement
The Court acknowledged a recent Supreme Court ruling stating that the filing of a criminal complaint before the DOJ and the conduct of preliminary investigation may toll prescription for criminal tax offenses. However, the majority treated that ruling as a new doctrine that should apply prospectively. Applying it retroactively, the Court reasoned, would prejudice an accused who was entitled to rely on the earlier doctrine that was prevailing when the alleged offense was committed.
The majority also reiterated the principle that laws on prescription of crimes must be interpreted in the manner more favorable to the accused. Because prescription is an act of liberality by the State, uncertainty in its application should not be resolved in a way that revives a criminal prosecution already barred under the doctrine applicable at the relevant time.
The Dissenting View
A dissenting opinion disagreed with the majority’s treatment of the newer Supreme Court pronouncement. The dissent took the position that the Supreme Court merely clarified the correct interpretation of Section 281 of the 1997 Tax Code, and that the filing of the criminal complaint before the DOJ should be treated as tolling prescription for criminal tax offenses covered by the 1997 Tax Code.
For the dissent, the newer rule should apply retroactively to criminal tax offenses under the 1997 Tax Code, not merely prospectively. The dissent emphasized that delays in preliminary investigation should not prejudice the State after it has already filed the complaint necessary to initiate prosecution.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Corporate Officers
This decision is important for taxpayers, responsible corporate officers, sole proprietors, and business owners facing criminal tax charges for alleged failure to pay deficiency taxes. Prescription is not a mere technical defense. It can determine whether the government still has the legal right to prosecute.
For taxpayers, the key dates matter. The date of mailing and assumed receipt of the final assessment, the lapse of the protest period, the date the assessment became due and demandable, the filing of the DOJ complaint, and the filing of the Information before the Court may all affect whether a criminal tax case was timely commenced.
For the BIR and prosecutors, the ruling underscores the importance of acting within the five-year period if the applicable doctrine requires the Information to be filed in the Court of Tax Appeals, and not merely referred for preliminary investigation. A delay of several years between DOJ referral and court filing may be fatal where the prosecution is unable to rely on a tolling rule.
For businesses, this case also shows why criminal tax exposure should be reviewed separately from civil tax assessment exposure. Even where a tax assessment exists, the government’s ability to prosecute a criminal offense may be barred if the statutory period to bring the criminal action has expired.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, corporate officers, importers, and business owners in Court of Tax Appeals litigation, BIR assessments, criminal tax exposure, and prescription defenses. Our tax litigation practice can evaluate assessment timelines, protest periods, DOJ referrals, Information filing dates, and procedural defects that may affect the validity of a criminal or civil tax case.
If you are facing a BIR assessment, a demand before suit, a tax evasion complaint, or a pending Court of Tax Appeals case, consult our tax litigation team through MakatiLawFirm.com for a focused review of your remedies, deadlines, and defenses.