A new income tax assessment first raised in the FLD/FAN was void for violating due process, and the taxpayer’s mailed protest was timely.
Taxpayers facing a BIR assessment should check whether the exact tax issue being collected was disclosed early enough in the audit process. A deficiency tax item that appears for the first time only in the Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notice may be vulnerable to cancellation if the taxpayer was denied a real chance to answer it at the informal conference and preliminary assessment stages.
Background of the Tax Dispute
The taxpayer was a securities broker registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission and with the BIR Revenue District Office in East Makati. For taxable year 2017, the BIR issued a Letter of Authority and later conducted an audit covering internal revenue taxes for the period from January 1, 2017 to December 31, 2017. The audit initially involved several tax types, including income tax, VAT, expanded withholding tax, documentary stamp tax, and improperly accumulated earnings tax.
At the Notice of Informal Conference stage, the BIR’s proposed income tax assessment was based on items such as disallowed expenses, unaccounted expenses, net operating loss carry-over, excess tax credits, and excess minimum corporate income tax carried forward. Later, at the Preliminary Assessment Notice stage, the BIR assessed income tax based on disallowed office supplies, donations, penalties, NOLCO, and MCIT-related adjustments. The taxpayer did not dispute the proposed income tax in the PAN and expressed willingness to pay it, while contesting the VAT assessment.
The controversy began when the BIR later issued the Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notice. Although the BIR dropped the earlier PAN income tax item because the taxpayer had paid it, the BIR introduced a new deficiency income tax assessment based on alleged undeclared income of P8,392,927.26. That amount came from comparing sales reported in the taxpayer’s VAT returns with sales or receipts reported in its annual income tax return. The BIR later upheld the assessment in the Final Decision on Disputed Assessment, in the total amount of P3,750,465.78, inclusive of increments. The taxpayer elevated the dispute to the tax court (CTA Case No. 10866).
The Commissioner’s Jurisdiction Argument Failed
The Commissioner first argued that the taxpayer’s administrative protest was filed out of time, and that the tax court therefore had no jurisdiction. The BIR claimed that the taxpayer received the FLD/FAN on November 13, 2020 and filed its protest only on January 6, 2021.
The tax court rejected that argument. The thirtieth day from the taxpayer’s receipt of the FLD/FAN fell on a Sunday, making the next working day, December 14, 2020, the deadline to file the protest. The taxpayer mailed its request for reinvestigation by registered mail on December 14, 2020. Applying RMC No. 15-2020, the court treated the mailing date shown by the post office stamp as the filing date. The January 6, 2021 stamp was only the BIR’s date of receipt, not the taxpayer’s filing date. The protest was therefore timely, and the tax court had jurisdiction to review the disputed assessment.
Why the New Income Tax Assessment Was Invalid
The central issue was whether the BIR could collect a new 2017 income tax assessment for alleged undeclared income when that specific basis was not presented in the NIC or PAN. The tax court said no.
The court emphasized that the Notice of Informal Conference and the Preliminary Assessment Notice are not empty formalities. They are due process mechanisms meant to inform the taxpayer of the factual and legal basis of the proposed assessment and to give the taxpayer an opportunity to explain, contest, or settle the issue before the BIR issues a final assessment.
In this case, the NIC did not inform the taxpayer that it was being assessed for income tax on alleged undeclared income arising from a comparison between VAT returns and the annual income tax return. The PAN also did not state that theory. It identified other income tax adjustments, but not the alleged unreported income item that later became the sole basis of the FLD/FAN and FDDA. Because the taxpayer was not told about that theory at the proper stages, it was deprived of the opportunity to present its side before the assessment became final in form.
Using VAT Return Figures for Another Tax Theory Was Not Enough
The Commissioner argued that the figures used to compute the alleged undeclared income already appeared in the PAN, because the PAN discussed sales per VAT returns and sales or receipts per annual income tax return in relation to a VAT issue. The tax court rejected this as insufficient.
The court explained that those figures were used in the PAN to determine receipts allegedly not subjected to VAT. They were not used to compute or explain an income tax assessment for undeclared income. A taxpayer cannot be expected to infer a separate income tax theory merely because some figures appear elsewhere in the assessment documents for a different tax type. Due process requires the BIR to disclose the actual facts, law, and computation supporting the specific tax being assessed.
RMC No. 11-2014 Did Not Save the Assessment
The Commissioner also relied on RMC No. 11-2014, arguing that the BIR could introduce a new deficiency tax item in the FLD/FAN when it was based on documents submitted by the taxpayer or admissions made during the protest. The tax court found no support for that position in the circular.
The court noted that RMC No. 11-2014 is silent on the supposed authority to introduce a new item of tax assessment for the first time in the FLD/FAN based on submitted documents or an alleged admission. Because the circular did not authorize that procedure, the BIR had no legal basis to bypass the taxpayer’s right to be informed and heard at the NIC and PAN stages.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers Under BIR Audit
For taxpayers, the ruling is a reminder that assessment procedure matters as much as accounting documentation. When the BIR shifts theories between the PAN and the FLD/FAN, the taxpayer should examine whether the final assessment is based on a new factual or legal ground that was never presented earlier. If so, the assessment may be void for violation of due process.
Companies should also preserve proof of timely filing of protests, especially when filing by registered mail. In this case, the registry receipt and post office stamp were critical because they established that the protest was filed on time even though the BIR received it later. For disputes involving the 30-day protest period, the difference between the date of mailing and the date of BIR receipt can determine whether the tax court may hear the case.
The ruling is particularly relevant to corporations whose VAT returns, income tax returns, financial statements, or books may show timing or classification differences. A discrepancy between VAT-reported receipts and income tax-reported revenues may invite BIR scrutiny, but the BIR must still clearly identify the tax theory, computation, and legal basis at the correct stage of the assessment process.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in BIR audits, administrative protests, requests for reinvestigation, assessment cancellation strategies, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can review PANs, FLD/FANs, FDDAs, protest deadlines, service issues, and due process defects to determine whether an assessment may be challenged or reduced.
For companies, executives, accountants, and individuals dealing with a tax assessment or a potential CTA appeal, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team.