The tax court dismissed the government’s Rule 65 challenge for lack of jurisdiction after a demurrer-based acquittal in a criminal tax case.
Taxpayers facing criminal tax cases before the Court of Tax Appeals gain a significant procedural advantage when the prosecution loses on demurrer to evidence: the government may still attempt a Rule 65 challenge, but the forum for that challenge can determine whether the petition survives at all. In this resolution, the tax court sitting en banc dismissed the government’s certiorari petition outright for lack of jurisdiction, leaving undisturbed the division’s grant of the accused taxpayer’s revised demurrer to evidence and the denial of the prosecution’s motion for reconsideration.
Background of the Criminal Tax Dispute
The case arose from criminal tax proceedings filed by the People of the Philippines, represented by the Solicitor General through the Bureau of Internal Revenue, against an accused taxpayer before a division of the Court of Tax Appeals. The division had earlier granted the accused’s revised demurrer to evidence in two criminal tax cases and later denied the prosecution’s motion for reconsideration. The government then filed a petition for certiorari before the tax court sitting en banc, alleging that the division committed grave abuse of discretion because the prosecution supposedly established the accused’s guilt for the charged tax offenses.
The resolution was promulgated on March 13, 2026, in a special civil action arising from the criminal tax cases (CTA EB SCA No. 0009). The central procedural issue was not whether the accused was actually guilty of the alleged Tax Code violations. Instead, the decisive question was whether the court sitting en banc had jurisdiction to entertain a Rule 65 petition challenging the division’s resolutions after the grant of a demurrer to evidence.
The Court Dismissed the Government’s Certiorari Petition
The majority dismissed the petition for lack of jurisdiction. It relied on the Supreme Court’s 2025 ruling in Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Nippon Express Philippines Corporation, which held that the Court of Tax Appeals sitting en banc has no jurisdiction over petitions for certiorari challenging interlocutory orders or judgments of a division. Under that doctrine, such petitions must be filed directly with the Supreme Court.
The majority reasoned that certiorari presupposes a hierarchical relationship, where a higher tribunal corrects jurisdictional errors of a lower or subordinate body. That relationship does not exist between the court sitting en banc and its divisions. They are not separate courts occupying different levels of judicial hierarchy; rather, they are configurations of the same collegial tax court. The majority further emphasized that the power of the court sitting en banc to review final decisions, resolutions, or orders of its divisions does not convert it into a superior tribunal with supervisory authority to issue writs of certiorari against its own divisions.
The majority also identified institutional concerns. Allowing the court sitting en banc to resolve certiorari petitions against division actions may result in a procedural dilemma because justices who participated in, or are institutionally connected to, the challenged division proceedings could be placed in a position of reviewing alleged grave abuse arising from the same court’s own acts. For the majority, this could impair collegiality, judicial neutrality, and public confidence in the appearance of fairness.
Why the Demurrer to Evidence Matters in Criminal Tax Cases
A demurrer to evidence in a criminal case is a powerful remedy for an accused taxpayer. When granted, it means the prosecution’s evidence is legally insufficient to sustain a conviction. In ordinary criminal procedure, the grant of a demurrer to evidence operates as an acquittal. Because an acquittal generally cannot be appealed without violating the constitutional protection against double jeopardy, the prosecution’s remaining remedy is narrow and extraordinary: certiorari based on grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction.
This is why the forum issue matters. In tax prosecutions, the government may believe that the division gravely abused its discretion by granting a demurrer and acquitting the accused. However, even when the government frames its challenge as a Rule 65 petition, it still has to file in the proper forum. In this resolution, the majority held that the court sitting en banc was not that forum and dismissed the government’s petition without reaching the merits of whether the prosecution’s evidence was sufficient.
The Dissents Viewed the Case Differently
Two dissenting opinions took a narrower view of the Nippon doctrine. They argued that Nippon dealt with interlocutory orders, meaning orders that do not finally dispose of the case. In their view, the present case was different because a grant of demurrer to evidence in a criminal case is tantamount to an acquittal and therefore constitutes a final disposition of the criminal action.
One dissent relied on the Supreme Court’s ruling in People v. Court of Tax Appeals – Third Division, Jacinto C. Ligot and Erlinda Y. Ligot, where a Rule 65 petition before the court sitting en banc was treated as a proper remedy to challenge an acquittal in a criminal tax case. The dissent reasoned that Ligot, not Nippon, should control where the challenged act is a judgment of acquittal rather than an interlocutory order. Under this view, the court sitting en banc should have assumed jurisdiction and given due course to the petition.
Another dissent agreed that the portion of the case involving the grant of demurrer should have been entertained under Rule 65 because the acquittal could not be appealed without violating double jeopardy. However, it also noted that a separate dismissal for lack of jurisdiction in another criminal case should have been challenged by appeal, not by certiorari, because appeal and certiorari are distinct and non-interchangeable remedies.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Corporate Officers
For taxpayers and corporate officers charged with criminal tax offenses, the ruling underscores the importance of a well-timed and well-supported demurrer to evidence. If the prosecution’s case is weak after it rests, a demurrer may end the criminal case without requiring the accused to present evidence. Once granted, the prosecution’s ability to overturn the result becomes procedurally limited and vulnerable to jurisdictional defenses.
For companies and individuals under BIR criminal investigation, the case also shows that tax litigation is not only about the substantive Tax Code violation alleged. Procedure can be outcome-determinative. Questions such as whether the order is final or interlocutory, whether the proper remedy is appeal or certiorari, and whether the petition was filed in the correct court can decide the case before the merits are reached.
For the government and private complainants assisting in tax enforcement matters, the ruling is a warning that post-acquittal remedies in criminal tax cases require careful forum selection. A mistaken procedural route may result in dismissal even if the prosecution believes the division gravely abused its discretion. The majority’s approach, if followed, points parties toward the Supreme Court for certain certiorari challenges involving division rulings, while the dissenting opinions preserve an argument that demurrer-based acquittals may still fall within the court sitting en banc’s Rule 65 jurisdiction under Ligot.
What This Means for Criminal Tax Defense Strategy
The ruling strengthens the defense value of attacking the prosecution’s evidence early and precisely. In criminal tax cases, the taxpayer’s counsel should scrutinize whether the prosecution established each element of the charged offense, including the accused’s participation, the specific Tax Code violation, and the evidentiary foundation for any alleged tax deficiency or failure. A demurrer should not merely argue that the defense has a better explanation; it should show that, even assuming the prosecution’s evidence is considered, conviction is legally unsustainable.
At the same time, counsel should prepare for the government’s possible resort to certiorari. A favorable demurrer ruling may not always end the procedural fight immediately. The defense must be ready to invoke double jeopardy, finality of acquittals, jurisdictional defects, and the strict limits of Rule 65 review. This resolution demonstrates that the procedural response to a government challenge may be just as important as the original demurrer itself.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, corporate officers, importers, and business owners involved in tax assessments, BIR investigations, customs disputes, and criminal tax litigation before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice helps clients evaluate exposure, prepare protest and defense strategies, challenge defective assessments or prosecutions, and respond to procedural remedies filed by the government.
If you or your company is facing a BIR criminal complaint, a Court of Tax Appeals case, a demurrer to evidence issue, or a post-acquittal government challenge, our team can help assess the procedural and substantive defenses available. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco regarding tax litigation, criminal tax defense, and Court of Tax Appeals strategy.