CTA grants BIR certiorari to correct RTC’s omission of civil tax liabilities in criminal cases, emphasizing statutory compliance and procedural safeguards.

Taxpayers, importers, and government agencies alike must now take note: the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) has clarified the proper exercise of civil liability collection in criminal tax cases. The ruling underscores that trial courts cannot disregard statutory civil and penal liabilities when adjudicating guilty pleas in tax offenses, and that agencies have recourse through certiorari when lower courts fail to act.

Background of the Case

In February 2023, the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) – Revenue Region I filed criminal cases against Datu Amerhassan Lucman y Geronimo, president of Royal AGL Quality Foods, Inc., for violations of Section 255 of the Tax Code for the taxable year 2018. The charges involved failure to accurately report and pay both Income Tax and Value-Added Tax (VAT). The Regional Trial Court (RTC) of San Fernando City, La Union arraigned the accused on July 5, 2023, who pleaded guilty to both offenses. The RTC imposed fines and prison terms but did not impose civil liabilities for the unpaid taxes (CTA SCA No. 0011, June 2025)

CTA 3rd Division Decision BUREA…

.

RTC’s Orders and BIR’s Motion

Petitioner BIR filed a Motion for Partial Reconsideration seeking imposition of civil liabilities corresponding to the VAT and Income Tax owed, inclusive of surcharges and interests. The RTC denied the motion on August 14, 2023, citing that the motion was filed beyond the 15-day reglementary period from promulgation of judgment, effectively precluding review of the civil aspect of the case. BIR then elevated the matter to the CTA through a petition for certiorari, claiming that the non-imposition of civil liability constituted grave abuse of discretion

CTA 3rd Division Decision BUREA…

.

CTA’s Legal Analysis

The CTA examined the jurisdiction and merits of the certiorari petition. Under Section 7 of the CTA Charter (RA 1125, as amended by RA 9282), the Court has appellate and supervisory jurisdiction over criminal tax cases originally decided by the RTC. The Court noted that judgments in criminal tax cases must include both penal and civil liabilities pursuant to Sections 205 and 256 of the Tax Code. Failure to impose civil liability or fines as required by law constitutes grave abuse of discretion and a violation of due process

CTA 3rd Division Decision BUREA…

CTA 3rd Division Decision BUREA…

.

Further, the Court emphasized that a motion for reconsideration cannot be deemed fatally late if there is no prior written order establishing civil liabilities. Because the RTC issued no written decision on the civil aspect, BIR could not have availed of ordinary remedies. The CTA therefore determined that certiorari was appropriate in this exceptional circumstance, satisfying the requirements of no plain, speedy, and adequate remedy

CTA 3rd Division Decision BUREA…

CTA 3rd Division Decision BUREA…

.

CTA Decision

The CTA granted BIR’s petition for certiorari, directing the RTC to conduct proceedings to determine the civil and penal liabilities of the accused with reasonable dispatch. The Court stressed that judgments must clearly state the facts, law, and justification for imposition or denial of civil liabilities to protect due process and enable review by higher courts. Any omission of civil liability or statutory penalties renders an order invalid and reviewable

CTA 3rd Division Decision BUREA…

CTA 3rd Division Decision BUREA…

.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Importers

For government agencies, this decision reinforces that civil and penal aspects of tax liability must be explicitly addressed in criminal tax cases, even when the accused pleads guilty. For taxpayers and corporate officers, it highlights the risk of facing both fines and civil liabilities despite early guilty pleas. Practically, businesses must ensure accurate tax reporting and timely compliance to avoid exposure to combined criminal and civil liabilities. Additionally, agencies and taxpayers should be vigilant in seeking recourse through certiorari when trial courts fail to adjudicate statutory obligations.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Our tax litigation team helps clients navigate complex criminal and civil tax matters, ensuring compliance and protecting rights in both the trial and appellate stages. Whether defending taxpayers, representing BIR, or advising on procedural remedies, we provide actionable guidance to minimize exposure and secure proper adjudication. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com
to learn more about our services.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *