A vice president not expressly named as a corporate officer in the by-laws remains an employee who may file illegal dismissal claims before the Labor Arbiter.

A managerial title does not automatically strip a worker of labor-law protection. A company vice president may still be treated as an ordinary employee, and may sue before the Labor Arbiter for illegal dismissal, unless the position is truly a corporate office created by law or expressly provided in the corporation’s by-laws.

Why This Ruling Matters to Executives, Companies, and Tax-Facing Corporate Teams

For business owners, finance heads, controllers, accountants, and senior managers, the decision in Matling Industrial and Commercial Corporation v. Coros is a warning against assuming that a high-ranking title automatically places a dispute outside the labor system. The label “Vice President,” “Finance Head,” “Administration Head,” or similar executive-sounding title is not controlling. What matters is how the position was legally created, who appointed the person, and whether the office is recognized as a corporate office under the Corporation Code or the company’s by-laws.

This is especially important for tax and corporate governance teams because finance and administration officers often handle sensitive corporate functions: accounting, compliance, reporting, disbursements, audit coordination, and documentation. Yet even if an officer performs highly confidential or managerial work, the company cannot avoid labor jurisdiction merely by arguing that the person was part of management. If the position is not a statutory or by-law corporate office, the employee remains protected by security of tenure.

Background: A Long-Time Finance Employee Was Dismissed as Vice President

Ricardo Coros had worked for Matling Industrial and Commercial Corporation for decades. He began as a bookkeeper in 1966 and rose through accounting, finance, and administrative positions until becoming Vice President for Finance and Administration in 1987. He was dismissed in 2000 and filed a complaint for illegal suspension and illegal dismissal before the labor tribunals.

Matling argued that the labor tribunals had no jurisdiction because Coros was allegedly a corporate officer, a director, and a stockholder. According to the company, his dismissal was an intra-corporate controversy, not an ordinary termination dispute. The case reached the Supreme Court, which resolved the jurisdictional question in a decision dated October 13, 2010 (G.R. No. 157802).

The Core Doctrine: Corporate Office by Law or By-Laws, Not by Title Alone

The Court drew a clear line between a corporate officer and an ordinary employee. Under the Corporation Code, corporate officers are those specifically identified by law, such as the president, treasurer, and secretary, plus other officers expressly provided in the by-laws. A position must be expressly mentioned in the by-laws to be treated as a corporate office.

The Court rejected the view that a general by-law clause authorizing the president to create offices was enough to create new corporate offices. That kind of clause may allow the president to create appointive or operational positions for business convenience, but it does not convert every such position into a corporate office. The power to elect corporate officers belongs to the board under the law and cannot simply be delegated to a subordinate officer or agent.

In Matling, the position of Vice President for Finance and Administration was not expressly listed as a corporate office in the by-laws. It was created by the president pursuant to an enabling provision. The Court therefore treated it as an ordinary corporate position, not a corporate office. Coros was an employee for purposes of his dismissal case.

Why Stock Ownership or Directorship Did Not Change the Result

The company also argued that because Coros was supposedly a stockholder and director, his dispute with the corporation was necessarily intra-corporate. The Court rejected that broad approach. Not every controversy between a corporation and a stockholder belongs in a corporate court. The Court emphasized that jurisdiction depends on both the relationship of the parties and the nature of the controversy.

Here, Coros was not appointed Vice President for Finance and Administration because he was a stockholder or director. He had already risen through the ranks long before any later claim of stockholder or director status. His dismissal affected his employment position, not his status as a stockholder or director. The dispute was therefore a labor termination dispute, not an intra-corporate controversy.

The Practical Test for Employers

For Philippine companies, the ruling creates a practical test. First, check whether the position is one of the officers named in the Corporation Code or expressly named in the by-laws. Second, check whether the person was elected by the board or stockholders in the manner required for corporate officers. Third, examine whether the controversy concerns corporate rights, such as election, appointment, removal from corporate office, shareholding, or governance, rather than ordinary employment termination.

If the answer points to an employment relationship, the case likely belongs before the Labor Arbiter. If the position is genuinely a corporate office and the controversy concerns appointment, election, or removal from that office, the case may be treated as an intra-corporate dispute cognizable by the proper Regional Trial Court under the framework following the Securities Regulation Code.

What This Means for Senior Managers and Finance Officers

Senior managers should not assume that accepting an executive title means surrendering labor rights. A finance or administration executive who rose from the ranks, performs regular functions integral to the business, and occupies a position not expressly created as a corporate office may still be a regular employee. That employee may invoke security of tenure and challenge dismissal before the labor tribunals.

For employers, the lesson is equally direct. Corporate titles must match corporate documents. If a company wants a position to be treated as a corporate office, the by-laws must expressly provide for it, and the appointment or election must follow the required corporate process. Otherwise, the company risks litigating dismissal before the labor tribunals despite the employee’s senior rank.

Corporate Governance and Labor Risk Must Be Aligned

The decision prevents corporations from using titles and broad by-law clauses to weaken employee security of tenure. A contrary rule would allow companies to label key employees as officers and remove them from labor-law protection without formally creating a corporate office in the manner required by law. The Court treated that possibility as inconsistent with fairness and the constitutional protection of labor.

For tax-facing organizations, this doctrine matters because finance and administration roles often sit at the intersection of corporate compliance, internal controls, and employment risk. A company may classify someone as a vice president for operational purposes, but that classification must be supported by the articles, by-laws, board action, employment records, and actual corporate practice.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises companies, executives, shareholders, and senior employees on disputes involving illegal dismissal, corporate officer status, intra-corporate controversies, board authority, and governance documentation. We help clients determine whether a dispute belongs before the Labor Arbiter or the regular courts, and we assist in structuring by-laws, board resolutions, employment contracts, and termination procedures to reduce litigation risk.

For legal advice on executive termination, corporate officer classification, labor disputes, or intra-corporate litigation in the Philippines, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *