State universities cannot use academic freedom or fiscal powers to grant unauthorized allowances, but good-faith employee recipients may avoid refund.
State universities and colleges may enjoy academic freedom and limited fiscal autonomy, but those powers do not automatically allow them to create employee allowances outside the Salary Standardization Law. The ruling teaches a practical rule for public institutions, auditors, and employees: income generated by a government university may be used for authorized university programs, but not for additional compensation unless the law clearly permits it. Even then, employees who received disallowed benefits in good faith may be spared from refund.
Why This Case Matters to Government Schools and Employees
The dispute arose when Benguet State University granted rice subsidy and health care allowances to its employees. The funds came from income derived from university operations and were given to employees under a board resolution. The Commission on Audit later disallowed the payments, treating them as unauthorized additional compensation.
Benguet State University challenged the disallowance, arguing that Republic Act No. 8292, the law governing state universities and colleges, gave its governing board authority to use income from tuition, auxiliary services, grants, donations, and similar sources for university purposes. It also invoked academic freedom, contending that the grant of benefits to employees supported the university’s institutional objectives. The case reached the Supreme Court in Benguet State University v. Commission on Audit (G.R. No. 169637), decided on June 8, 2007.
The Doctrine: Fiscal Autonomy Is Not a Blank Check for Benefits
The Supreme Court held that Benguet State University had no authority to grant the rice subsidy and health care allowances. The Court read the university’s statutory powers in context. While R.A. No. 8292 allowed state universities and colleges to retain certain income and disburse it for projects of the university, the Court emphasized that such authority was tied to the institution’s educational mission.
The key statutory phrase was the authority to use funds for