Resigning Will Not Erase Liability for Taking Government Property

The Supreme Court held that resignation does not erase liability for unauthorized taking of government property, imposing a fine for serious dishonesty. Public employees cannot avoid administrative liability by resigning after government property is taken without authority. The Supreme Court made clear that even a low-ranking court employee who removes office supplies, calls them scrap, […]

When a Government Employeeโ€™s Mistake Is Not Enough for Dismissal

Supreme Court reduced a public employeeโ€™s Ombudsman dismissal to suspension, restoring forfeited benefits after finding only simple misconduct and dishonesty. Government employees may be held liable for processing defective documents, but dismissal is not automatic unless the evidence shows corruption, willful violation of law, or a level of dishonesty serious enough to justify the harshest […]

Bank Deposit Alone Cannot Prove Grave Misconduct: Why Public Officers Need More Than Suspicion to Be Dismissed

A bank deposit alone did not prove grave misconduct; the Supreme Court cleared an NLRC official and ordered backwages and retirement benefits. A public officer cannot be dismissed for grave misconduct based on speculation from a bank deposit alone. Even in administrative cases, where the standard of proof is only substantial evidence, the government must […]

Resignation Cannot Erase Court Personnel Liability for Irregular Fees and Fixing

Court personnel may still be fined, lose benefits, and be barred from government employment after resigning over irregular fees and fixing allegations. Judiciary employees who resign after being accused of irregular collections, fixing, or other conduct that damages public trust may still be fined, lose benefits, and be permanently barred from government employment. The Supreme […]

Taguig City Local Business Tax Refund Upheld for Union Cement Holdings

CTA upholds UCHC refund of local business taxes after Taguig City applied presumptive income method without ordinance or public hearings, confirming taxpayer rights. Local business taxpayers now have a clear path to challenge assessments based on arbitrary presumptive income levels. The Court of Tax Appeals recently affirmed the refund claim of Union Cement Holdings Corporation […]

Court Employees Cannot Escape Liability by Retiring After Mishandling Public Funds

Court employees who mishandle judiciary funds remain liable despite retirement, resignation, or repayment, with benefits forfeited and criminal action ordered. Retirement, resignation, repayment, illness, or personal hardship will not erase administrative liability when a court employee mishandles public funds. The Supreme Court reaffirmed that clerks of court and officers-in-charge who collect judiciary money act as […]

When Illegal Government Allowances Need Not Be Refunded

Supreme Court upheld COAโ€™s COLA disallowance but excused refund due to finality, due process, lapse of time, and social justice under Madera. Government employees and local officials may still be spared from refunding disallowed benefits, even when the Commission on Audit correctly finds the payment illegal, if requiring repayment years later would be inequitable, prejudicial, […]

Judiciary Health Care Coverage Now Includes Voluntary Enrollment for Dependents and Retirees

Judiciary personnel and eligible dependents must follow strict enrollment, eligibility, and premium payment rules for voluntary HMO coverage under the new plan. Judges, court officials, employees, qualified dependents, and certain retirees now have a defined enrollment window and premium structure for health care coverage under the Judiciaryโ€™s comprehensive health care program, making timely registration and […]

Tax Assessments Void When Due Process Ignored in Philippine BIR Case

CTA ruled that BIR deficiency assessments are void if due process is violated, emphasizing written notice and consideration of taxpayer defenses. Businesses engaging in importation, manufacturing, and local trade must ensure that deficiency tax assessments issued by the Bureau of Internal Revenue comply strictly with procedural due process. Tax assessments that fail to provide taxpayers […]

Due Process Violation Voids Electric Cooperative Tax Assessment

The CTA nullified Pampanga Rural Electric’s 2013 income tax assessment due to violation of administrative due process, emphasizing taxpayers must be given proper notice and time to respond. Electric cooperatives and other nonprofit entities must now be aware that the premature issuance of a tax assessment, before the taxpayer has had a fair opportunity to […]