Regalian Presumption Rule: Public Land Claims in Philippine Property Disputes

Public land remains State-owned unless private claimants prove alienable status; long possession cannot defeat the Regalian presumption. The Regalian Presumption Rule means that people occupying public land cannot defeat the State’s claim by long possession alone. In Philippine property disputes involving untitled or public land, the decisive question is not simply who stayed there longer, […]

Government Instrumentality Tax Shield: LRTA Real Property Tax Exemption

Government instrumentalities with public-use properties are exempt from local real property tax; private beneficial users may still be taxed. Government instrumentalities with corporate powers are protected from local real property tax when their properties are devoted to public use, even if they collect fees from the public. For cities, this ruling limits the power to […]

When Government Bonuses Must Be Returned: COA Disallowance, Special Trust Funds, and the Limits of Good Faith

Government employees may be required to refund unauthorized incentives after COA disallowance, even without fraud, when public funds lacked legal basis. Government employees who receive unauthorized bonuses or incentives may be ordered to return them even if they acted without fraud and believed the payment was valid. For state universities and other public institutions, the […]

Assessed Value Rule: Why Property Cases Get Dismissed

Property cases involving title or possession require assessed value in the complaint; market value alone cannot establish court jurisdiction. Property owners who file reconveyance, annulment of title, or possession cases must plead the assessed value of the land, not merely its market value, or risk outright dismissal for lack of jurisdiction. The Assessed Value Jurisdiction […]

Bouncing Checks, Corporate Officers, and the Notice Rule: When Personal Liability Survives a Corporate Signature

The Supreme Court held that B.P. 22 liability requires proof of notice of dishonor and that corporate officers may still face personal liability for bounced checks. Corporate officers who sign company checks cannot automatically escape personal exposure by invoking the corporation’s separate personality, especially when they personally undertook the obligation behind the checks. But a […]

Boundary Dispute Rule: Why Forcible Entry Cannot Decide Land Titles

Boundary disputes over titled land cannot be decided by forcible entry; parties must file the proper property action to resolve ownership. Boundary disputes over titled land cannot be shortcut through a summary ejectment case. When the real controversy is whether a disputed portion falls within one party’s Torrens title or another party’s claimed property, the […]

Homeowners Can Recover Damages When Association Rules Are Enforced in Bad Faith

Homeowners may recover damages and attorney’s fees before the housing agency when an association enforces construction restrictions in bad faith. Homeowners who are forced to fight their own association over discriminatory or bad-faith restrictions may recover moral damages, exemplary damages, attorney’s fees, and litigation expenses in the same housing dispute, without having to file a […]

Dividend Tax Refund Rule: Foreign Investors Can Sue for Overpaid Tax

Foreign investors may sue for dividend tax refunds when they merely hold shares and prove overpaid withholding tax within the deadline. Foreign corporate shareholders may recover overpaid Philippine dividend taxes even without a Philippine license, so long as their local activity is merely an investment and not doing business. The Dividend Tax Refund Rule matters […]

Accion Publiciana Title Rule: Possession Is Not Reconveyance

Accion publiciana may decide ownership only provisionally; courts cannot order reconveyance or defeat a Torrens title in a possession case in Philippines. The Accion Publiciana Title Rule protects registered landowners from losing titled property through a possession case. A court hearing an accion publiciana may look at ownership only to decide who has the better […]