Tax Appeal Equity Rule: Late CTA Appeals May Still Be Heard

A late CTA tax appeal may proceed when BIR assessment instructions caused confusion and no final decision had resolved the taxpayer’s protest. The Tax Appeal Equity Rule protects taxpayers from losing their day in court when a late Court of Tax Appeals filing was caused by the tax authority’s own confusing assessment instructions and when […]

Mandanas Doctrine: LGU Shares Must Come From All National Taxes

LGU shares must be computed from all national taxes, but past arrears are barred under the prospective Mandanas Doctrine. The Mandanas Doctrine changed the fiscal baseline for local governments: the constitutional share of provinces, cities, municipalities, and barangays must be computed from all national taxes, not only national internal revenue taxes. For local officials, taxpayers, […]

Reconstituted Title Due Diligence: When Land Buyers Lose Protection

Buyers of administratively reconstituted titles must investigate defects; a title from a void source gives no valid ownership rights. Land buyers cannot rely blindly on an administratively reconstituted title and later claim good faith when ownership is challenged. The Reconstituted Title Due Diligence Doctrine requires purchasers, lenders, developers, and lessees to investigate defects when the […]

Public Dominion Tax Sale Rule: SC Bars Auction of Government Property

Government property of public dominion cannot be auctioned for real property tax; LGUs must pursue the taxable beneficial user instead. The Public Dominion Tax Sale Rule protects government-owned property from being sold at public auction even when real property taxes are allegedly unpaid. For local governments, tax collection power is real but not unlimited. For […]

False MCLE Declarations Can Cost a Lawyer Years of Practice and Put a Client’s Case at Risk

A lawyer’s false MCLE exemption claim led to a three-year suspension and showed how defective attorney compliance can endanger client pleadings. A lawyer who falsely claims MCLE exemption in court filings can be suspended from practice, and the client may suffer the practical consequence of pleadings being expunged or treated as legally ineffective. For litigants, […]

Oral Partition Rule: When Heirs Lose Stale Property Claims

Oral partition among heirs can defeat stale land claims when possession, tax declarations, and decades of silence prove accepted ownership. The oral partition rule protects heirs and buyers who have possessed inherited property for decades under an agreed family division: a written deed is not always required to prove that co-heirs already divided an estate, […]

BOT Tax Exemption Rule: When LGUs Can Collect Real Property Tax

BOT assets used by a private operator remain taxable; a GOCC cannot pass its real property tax exemption through contract assumptions. Tax exemptions in build-operate-transfer projects do not automatically pass from a government corporation to its private project proponent. Under the BOT Tax Exemption Rule, a government-owned corporation cannot shield privately owned and operated project […]

Educational Tax Exemption: SC Protects Nonprofit Schools

Nonprofit schools keep tax exemption despite surpluses if revenues are used directly for education; SC cancelled a P122.4M tax assessment. Non-stock, non-profit schools do not lose their constitutional tax exemption merely because they earn surpluses, collect substantial tuition, or maintain large cash reserves, so long as their revenues and assets are actually, directly, and exclusively […]

MCIT Direct Cost Rule: Insurance Taxes Are Not Service Costs

For MCIT, insurance premium taxes and DST are not direct service costs; policy coverage increases can trigger additional DST liability. The MCIT Direct Cost Rule matters because companies cannot reduce minimum corporate income tax by treating every business-related tax or expense as a cost of service. For Philippine corporations, especially insurance companies and other service […]