When a Void SEC Ruling Still Cannot Cancel a Land Title Automatically

A void SEC ruling could not automatically cancel a Torrens title; parties must use the proper court action to challenge title transfers and related property rights. A void judgment creates no rights, but the party injured by it must still use the correct remedy before the correct court. For property owners, corporations, and taxpayers dealing […]

Condo Owners Can Void Board Elections Held Without the Right Quorum

The Supreme Court voided a condominium corporation election for lack of quorum, clarifying member attendance, developer rights, and proxy limits. Condominium corporations cannot validate a board election by counting voting weight as if it were the same as member attendance. For unit owners, the practical rule is powerful: when a non-stock condominium corporation holds a […]

Full-Year Tax Relief Doctrine: SC Voids BIR Prorating Rule

Taxpayers may claim full-year 2008 R.A. 9504 relief; BIR cannot prorate exemptions or strip minimum wage earners of wage-tax exemptions by regulation. The Full-Year Tax Relief Doctrine protects taxpayers from administrative regulations that reduce statutory tax benefits by prorating them without clear authority from Congress. For employees, employers, payroll teams, and tax managers, the ruling […]

When a President Is a Corporate Officer, the NLRC Cannot Award Illegal Dismissal Damages

Corporate officers named in by-laws cannot pursue removal disputes as ordinary NLRC illegal dismissal cases; the proper forum is the regular court. Corporate presidents and other officers named in a corporation’s by-laws cannot automatically treat their removal as an ordinary illegal dismissal case before the NLRC. If the dispute concerns the election, appointment, term, or […]

Material Evidence Remand Rule in Philippine Property Disputes

Land title disputes may be remanded when late evidence raises serious doubts on deeds, notarization, and ownership documents. The Material Evidence Remand Rule gives property litigants a critical safeguard: when late-submitted documents raise serious doubts about land titles, courts may reopen factual inquiry rather than let ownership turn on technical procedure alone. For landowners, buyers, […]

Corporate Fiduciary Breaches Are Not Automatically Crimes

The Supreme Court held that director disloyalty under Sections 31 and 34 creates civil liability, not automatic criminal liability under Section 144. Corporate directors and officers may face serious civil liability for disloyalty, bad faith, or corporate opportunity violations, but they cannot be criminally prosecuted unless Congress clearly made the act a crime. The ruling […]

Local Tax Ordinance Challenges: Why Procedure Can Defeat Tax Cases

Taxpayers challenging local tax ordinances must first use DOJ remedies and proper courts, or risk dismissal despite serious tax claims. Taxpayers challenging a local tax ordinance must usually go first to the Secretary of Justice and the proper lower court before asking the Supreme Court to intervene. The local tax ordinance procedure rule means that […]

Mining Contract Disputes Must Go to Arbitration When Parties Agreed to Arbitrate

The Supreme Court dismissed parallel mining contract cases for forum shopping and enforced arbitration despite attempts to proceed in court. Businesses that agree to arbitrate cannot avoid that bargain by filing parallel cases before courts and administrative agencies, especially when both cases arise from the same contract, seek substantially the same relief, and risk conflicting […]

Corporate Officers Cannot Be Made Personally Liable by Execution Alone

Corporate officers cannot be made personally liable for labor judgments by execution alone without summons, due process, and proof of bad faith. Business owners and corporate officers cannot be made personally liable for a corporation’s labor judgment simply because the company cannot pay. A final award against a corporation does not automatically become a personal […]

When a Corporation Keeps Money Without Board Approval, It May Still Have to Return It

A corporation lacking board consent may avoid contract liability, but it cannot keep money received without legal basis; refund, interest, and damages may follow. A company cannot avoid refund liability by saying it never approved a transaction, while also keeping money paid because of that same transaction. When corporate consent is absent, the supposed contract […]