FEZ Tax Immunity Rule: When Tax Regulations Go Too Far

FEZ enterprises cannot be forced to pay VAT or excise tax first when the law exempts the goods; refund remedies cannot replace tax immunity. The FEZ Tax Immunity Rule protects freeport and economic zone enterprises from being forced to pay VAT and excise taxes first, then fight for a refund later, when the law already […]

Assessed Value Jurisdiction Rule: Property Cases Can Be Voided

Accion publiciana must plead assessed value; otherwise RTC jurisdiction fails, property judgments become void, and landowners may need to refile correctly. Property owners who file recovery of possession cases must plead the assessed value of the land at the very start, or risk losing the entire case no matter how strong their ownership papers appear. […]

Public Land Compensation Rule: When Long Possession Must Be Paid

Alienable public land may require compensation when heirs prove qualifying possession since June 12, 1945 despite no registered title. Families occupying alienable public land are not automatically owners merely because they have possessed it for decades, but they may still be entitled to just compensation when they can prove open, continuous, exclusive, and notorious possession […]

Regalian Presumption Rule: Why Land Registration Failed

Land registration fails when claimants cannot prove alienable land status and possession since 1945 under the Regalian doctrine. The Regalian Presumption Rule means that a person claiming ownership over untitled or unregistered land must defeat the State’s presumed ownership with strict, documentary proof. Long occupation, family memory, tax declarations, and neighborhood testimony may help, but […]

Land Registration Proof Rule: Why Tax Declarations Are Not Enough

Tax declarations alone do not prove land ownership; registration requires possession since 1945 and official alienable land classification. The Land Registration Proof Rule requires applicants for original land registration to prove more than long possession, tax payments, or an approved survey plan. A person who wants private title over land of the public domain must […]

Educational Tax Exemption Rule: When School Revenues Avoid Tax

Non-stock, non-profit schools avoid income tax and VAT only by proving revenues were used directly and exclusively for education. Non-stock, non-profit schools can defeat income tax, VAT, and local business tax assessments when they prove that the revenues being taxed were used actually, directly, and exclusively for educational purposes. The Educational Revenue Use Doctrine matters […]

PAGCOR Tax Exemption Rule: VAT Exempt, But Withholding Still Applies

PAGCOR remains VAT-exempt under its charter, but must still comply with withholding tax duties when benefits or payments are taxable. The PAGCOR Tax Exemption Rule protects a statutory franchise holder from VAT when its special charter was not expressly repealed, but it does not erase separate withholding duties imposed on the employer or withholding agent. […]

Non-Stock Associations Cannot Expel Members or Transfer Community Property Without Due Process and Corporate Purpose

The Supreme Court voided improper association expulsions and land transfers, protecting members’ due process, inspection rights, and corporate property. Members of a non-stock association are not powerless when officers remove them without notice or transfer association property to insiders. The Supreme Court confirmed that membership cannot be terminated by shortcut, and corporate property cannot be […]

Corporate Officers Are Not Automatically Personally Liable for Company Labor Debts

Corporate officers are not personally liable for company labor debts unless bad faith is alleged, proven, and adjudged before execution. Business owners and corporate officers are not automatically required to pay a corporation’s labor judgment from their personal assets merely because the company has closed or cannot satisfy the award. Personal liability requires more than […]