Public Use Withdrawal Rule: When Expropriation Must Stop

Expropriation must stop when public use disappears, but withdrawal may still require payment, damages, or court review for prejudiced landowners. The Public Use Withdrawal Rule protects landowners from being trapped in an expropriation case after the government itself admits that it no longer needs the property for the stated public project. For property owners, the […]

Suspended Lawyers Cannot Represent Even Their Own Spouses in Court

A suspended lawyer cannot appear even for a spouse. The Court imposed a further six-month suspension for unauthorized practice during an active suspension. A suspended lawyer is barred from doing more than accepting paid clients: the prohibition covers every act that requires legal knowledge, including signing as counsel, examining witnesses, and appearing in court for […]

When a Settlement Exists, a Lawyer Cannot Let the Court Decide in the Dark

A lawyer was suspended for failing to disclose a settlement to the court, showing that withdrawal or forgiveness cannot erase proven misconduct. Lawyers who obtain a favorable judgment while keeping silent about a prior settlement risk professional discipline, because candor to the court does not end when the opposing party stops appearing or later asks […]

A Lawyerโ€™s Private Life Can End a Legal Career When It Makes a Mockery of Marriage

The Supreme Court disbarred a lawyer who knowingly contracted a second marriage despite a subsisting first marriage, but dismissed charges against another lawyer for lack of proof. Lawyers may lose the right to practice law for private conduct that reveals a serious defect in moral character, especially when they knowingly use legal maneuvering to create […]

When a Wrong Legal Call Becomes Discipline: The Honest Error Rule for Lawyers and Labor Arbiters

A labor arbiterโ€™s possible legal error is not automatically misconduct, but lawyers may still be reprimanded for ignoring Court and IBP orders. Not every mistaken ruling by a lawyer acting as a labor arbiter is professional misconduct. A party who believes a labor arbiter wrongly pierced the corporate veil must usually challenge that ruling through […]

Sexual Harassment Complaints Against Judges Still Require Proof, Not Suspicion Alone

The Supreme Court dismissed a sexual harassment complaint against a judge, holding that serious allegations still require substantial evidence and moral certainty. Administrative complaints for sexual harassment in the Judiciary may begin with an anonymous report, but they cannot end in discipline unless the accusation is proven by substantial evidence and creates moral certainty from […]

When Government Takes Land, Who Pays the Taxes and Fees?

Supreme Court clarifies who pays taxes in expropriation: sellers bear capital gains tax, while DPWH may shoulder DST, transfer tax, and fees. Property owners whose land is expropriated for public infrastructure are not automatically responsible for every tax and transfer cost. In this ruling, the Supreme Court drew a practical line: the landowner must bear […]

When Absences Become Dismissal: The Supreme Courtโ€™s Hard Line on AWOL Government Employees

Repeated AWOL by a government employee may justify dismissal, forfeiture of benefits, and disqualification from future public service. Government employees who repeatedly go absent without leave may lose not only their position, but also their future eligibility for public employment. In Leave Divisionโ€“O.A.S. v. Sarceno, the Supreme Court treated habitual absenteeism not as a mere […]

Court Employees Cannot Escape Liability for Missing Public Funds by Resigning

Court personnel who mishandle court funds remain liable despite resignation or retirement, with penalties including forfeiture, restitution, fines, and criminal referral. Public officers who handle court money remain accountable even after they resign or retire. When court funds, cash bonds, fiduciary deposits, or legal fee collections are not deposited on time, the Supreme Court may […]

When an Admitted Debt Becomes a Disciplinary Case for Court Personnel

An admitted debt can discipline court personnel even without a judgment. The Court classified six years of nonpayment as willful failure to pay just debts. Public employees, especially court personnel, cannot treat an admitted debt as a purely private matter when their refusal to pay undermines public confidence in their office. The doctrine in Tordilla […]