A Corporate Officer Cannot Force a Criminal Case Without Authority From the Company

A corporate officer cannot force prosecutors to file a criminal case for a company claim without proper authority from the corporation. Corporate officers, minority shareholders, and directors cannot use a criminal complaint to recover a company claim unless they can show authority to act for the corporation. Even when a prosecutor commits a procedural mistake, […]

Family Business Profits Are Not Partnership Shares Without Proof of Intent

Family business involvement does not prove partnership. The Court required clear evidence of contribution, common fund, and intent to share profits. Heirs cannot claim a share in a family business as partnership property merely because a deceased relative helped build the enterprise, managed operations, lived near the business, or received payments connected with its success. […]

Treasury Shares Do Not Erase Sequestration: What Disputed Corporate Stock Means for Dividends, Voting Rights, and Tax Planning

Disputed sequestered shares cannot simply be treated as treasury shares or stripped of dividends while ownership remains under court review. Corporate shares under government sequestration cannot be converted into treasury shares, stripped of voting rights, or relieved of dividend consequences merely because a company wants to restructure a disputed settlement. For business owners, investors, and […]

When Government Ownership Does Not End SEC Control

Government ownership does not automatically remove a Corporation Code entity from SEC control; stockholders may still compel meetings and director elections. A corporation cannot avoid ordinary corporate governance rules simply because the government owns or controls most of its shares. Where the entity was organized under the Corporation Code, stockholders may still invoke the Securities […]

Corporate Officer Removal Is Not an Illegal Dismissal Case When the Dispute Is Really Intra-Corporate

Corporate officers removed from board-created positions may have intra-corporate disputes, not NLRC illegal dismissal claims, if the issue is corporate office removal. A corporate officer removed from a board-created position cannot automatically convert the dispute into an illegal dismissal case before the Labor Arbiter. When the claim is rooted in the person’s status as a […]

When a Tax Refund Statute Has a Ceiling, Later Tax Increases Do Not Raise the Refund

Mining tax refunds are capped by the refund statute itself; later fuel tax increases do not enlarge the refund absent clear legal authority. Taxpayers claiming statutory refunds cannot enlarge the refund by relying on later tax increases unless the refund law itself clearly says so. For mining and lumber companies that paid specific taxes on […]

Mining Fuel Tax Refunds Are Limited to Taxes Actually Paid, Not Later Higher Rates

Mining fuel tax refunds are limited to taxes actually paid or deemed paid; later higher tax rates cannot enlarge a statutory refund claim. Tax refunds for fuel used in mining operations cannot be enlarged by later tax increases, even when the taxpayer is legally entitled to a refund. A mining company claiming the 25% refund […]

When a Business Closes, Employees May Still Be Entitled to Separation Pay

Employees may recover separation pay after business closure unless serious losses are proven; corporate officers are not automatically personally liable. Employees may still recover separation pay when a business shuts down, unless the employer proves that the closure was caused by serious business losses or financial reverses. But corporate officers are not automatically personally liable […]