When a Dismissal Is Not a Labor Case: Corporate Officers Must Sue in the Proper Forum

Corporate officers removed by board action may need to sue in the corporate forum, not the NLRC, even when they seek compensation or retainer fees. Corporate officers who are removed from management cannot automatically treat the dispute as an ordinary illegal dismissal case. When the controversy arises from the removal, appointment, or liability of a […]

When Corporate Losses Excuse a Wage Increase: Why Paid-Up Capital Must Be Legally Real

The Court held that unapproved future share subscriptions are not paid-up capital, allowing a distressed employer to prove capital impairment for wage exemption. Employers seeking exemption from a wage increase because of financial distress must prove capital impairment using legally recognized paid-up capital, not proposed subscriptions, advance payments, or capital increases that have not yet […]

Loss of Confidence Still Requires Proof: When Managers Can Fight Dismissal in the Philippines

Managers cannot be fired on suspicion alone. Loss of confidence requires proof and due process, while corporate officers are not personally liable absent bad faith. Employers cannot dismiss even high-trust managers on suspicion alone: loss of confidence must rest on substantial evidence, and the employee must receive notice and a real chance to answer before […]

When a Court Order Hands Over Company Property Without a Hearing, It Can Be Voided

A corporate faction cannot use an emergency order to seize disputed company property without notice, hearing, and bond, though receivership may preserve assets. A party fighting over corporate control cannot be forced to surrender factories, buildings, machines, and corporate records through an emergency order that effectively decides possession before the opposing side is heard. The […]

When a Firing Is Really a Corporate Dispute: Stockholder-Officers Must Go to the Corporate Forum, Not the NLRC

Stockholder-officers alleging illegal dismissal may be outside NLRC jurisdiction when the dispute is truly intra-corporate and rooted in corporate management. Corporate officers who are also stockholders cannot automatically frame their removal as an ordinary illegal dismissal case before the NLRC. When the dispute arises from their status as directors, officers, or stockholders, and the controversy […]

Employee Gratuity Pay Cannot Be Defeated by Corporate Technicalities After the Company Has Already Honored It

A company that ratifies employee gratuity pay through conduct and partial payment cannot later avoid liability through corporate technicalities. Employers that approve gratuity or retirement-style benefits for employees may remain bound even if they later claim defects in board notice, stockholder approval, or corporate authority, especially when the company has already begun paying the benefit […]

When a Corporate Officer Is Removed, the Labor Arbiter May Not Be the Right Forum

Corporate officers removed from board-created posts may belong in an intra-corporate forum, not the NLRC, even when they seek reinstatement and backwages. A corporate officer who is removed from an elected or appointed corporate post cannot automatically treat the dispute as an ordinary illegal dismissal case before the Labor Arbiter. When the controversy is rooted […]

Sandiganbayan Cannot Hear Every PCGG-Related Corporate Dispute

The Supreme Court held that Sandiganbayan cannot hear prohibition, mandamus, or quo warranto petitions without an express legal grant of jurisdiction. Not every dispute involving a sequestered corporation belongs in the Sandiganbayan. Even when the Presidential Commission on Good Government participates in, influences, or prompts a corporate act, a party seeking prohibition, mandamus, or quo […]