Late Government Motions Can End Criminal Tax Cases Before Trial

The Court affirmed dismissal of a criminal tax case, underscoring prescription, strict motion deadlines, and procedural defenses in BIR prosecutions. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges should not assume that a government appeal or reconsideration will automatically revive a dismissed case. Where the prosecution misses mandatory procedural deadlines, the dismissal of a tax criminal case may […]

Customs Criminal Case Dismissed After Prosecution Failed to Prove Probable Cause

Customs criminal Information dismissed without prejudice after the prosecution failed to submit documents needed to establish probable cause. Importers, customs brokers, and business owners facing criminal customs charges should understand that an Information for alleged violations of the Tariff and Customs Code cannot stand on incomplete supporting records. Where the prosecution fails to submit the […]

Tax Evasion Case Dismissed After Government Filed Too Late

Criminal tax charges for failure to pay deficiency taxes were dismissed after the government filed beyond the five-year Tax Code prescriptive period. Taxpayers and corporate officers facing criminal tax charges should closely examine not only the alleged deficiency tax, but also when the assessment became final and when the government actually filed the criminal case. […]

Criminal Tax Cases Can Fail When the BIR Files Too Late or Builds on a Defective Assessment

A tax crime case for alleged failure to pay deficiency income tax was dismissed because prosecution was filed late and the assessment was defective. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges should not assume that a final assessment automatically results in conviction. When the government files a tax crime case beyond the five-year prescriptive period, or when […]

Invalid BIR Audit Authority Can Defeat Criminal Tax Charges for Willful Failure to Pay

A tax prosecution for willful failure to pay failed because the assessment was void, notice was unproven, and the Information was filed beyond the five-year period. Corporate officers facing criminal tax charges for alleged willful failure to pay taxes cannot be convicted merely because the BIR says an assessment became final. The prosecution must still […]

Tax Evasion Cases Can Be Dismissed When Prosecutors Miss the Prescriptive Period

A criminal Tax Code case was dismissed on prescription, reminding taxpayers and prosecutors that delayed filing can defeat even serious tax violation charges. Tax officers and prosecutors must act within the criminal prescriptive period when pursuing Tax Code violations, because even serious allegations of non-filing or tax evasion may be dismissed if the government waits […]

Tax Evasion Cases Can Be Lost Before Trial When the Information Is Filed Too Late

A criminal tax case stayed dismissed after the CTA held that filing a DOJ complaint did not interrupt prescription; the information must be filed in court on time. Tax prosecutors must file the information in the Court of Tax Appeals within the five-year prescriptive period for Tax Code offenses; a complaint filed with the Department […]

Late Reconsideration Cannot Revive a Prescribed Criminal Tax Case

Criminal tax charges were dismissed after the court found prescription and denied a late prosecution reconsideration motion filed beyond the five-day period. Taxpayers and responsible corporate officers facing criminal tax charges should pay close attention to prescription and procedural deadlines, because even the government may lose its right to prosecute when the Information is filed […]

Illegal Cigarette Excise Tax Case Fails After Invalid Vehicle Search

A cigarette excise tax prosecution failed after the Court excluded seized goods from an invalid vehicle search, defeating both conviction and civil tax liability. Tax enforcement cases involving cigarettes, fuel, alcohol, and other excisable goods can collapse if the government’s evidence is obtained through an unconstitutional search. For taxpayers, importers, logistics providers, truckers, and drivers, […]

Invalid BIR Service Can Defeat Criminal Tax Charges and Civil Collection Claims

Improper service of the BIR Letter of Authority and assessment notices led to acquittal and no civil tax liability for alleged willful failure to pay tax. Taxpayers facing criminal charges for alleged willful failure to pay deficiency taxes may defeat both conviction and civil liability when the government cannot prove that the Letter of Authority, […]