Corporate Officers Cannot Turn Board Removal Into an Ordinary Illegal Dismissal Case

Corporate officer removal by board action may be an intra-corporate controversy, not an NLRC illegal dismissal case. Forum choice can decide the dispute. A corporate officer removed by board action may not automatically sue before the labor tribunal for illegal dismissal, because the dispute may be an intra-corporate controversy rather than an ordinary employer-employee case. […]

Automatic Return-to-Work Doctrine: Illegal Strikes in Labor Disputes

Assumption of jurisdiction automatically orders strikers back to work; defiance makes the strike illegal and may justify loss of employment status. The Automatic Return-to-Work Doctrine means that once the Secretary of Labor assumes jurisdiction over a labor dispute or certifies it for compulsory arbitration, striking workers must immediately return to work even if no separate […]

When Unpaid Officer Compensation Is Not a Labor Case: Stockholder-Officers Must Sue in the Corporate Forum

Officer-stockholder pay claims tied to corporate office are intracorporate disputes, not ordinary labor cases, and must be filed in the proper forum. A corporate officer who is also a stockholder may not automatically treat unpaid salaries, per diems, allowances, and similar benefits as an ordinary labor claim. When the compensation being claimed is tied to […]

Retirement Benefits Cannot Be Denied by Arbitrary Management Discretion

Management discretion cannot defeat vested retirement benefits without due process, good faith, and clear compelling reasons. Corporate officers may be personally liable. Employers cannot defeat an employeeโ€™s vested retirement benefits by invoking management discretion as if it were unlimited power. When a retirement plan forms part of an employeeโ€™s compensation package, discretion must be exercised […]

Funders Are Not Automatically Employers: When Labor Claims Cannot Be Filed Against a Donor or Supporting Organization

A project funder was not liable as employer where a separate center controlled the workers; closure of the project supported lawful termination. A charity, donor, project funder, or supporting organization is not automatically the employer of workers simply because it finances a program. The controlling question is still who hired, supervised, controlled, and could dismiss […]

GOCC Employees Can Unionize When Their Corporation Has No Original Charter

GOCC employees in corporations without original charters may unionize under the Labor Code and seek certification elections, instead of being barred by civil service labor rules. Employees of government-owned corporations created under the general corporation law may organize unions and demand a certification election under the Labor Code, because they are treated differently from civil […]

Medical Expense Cutoff Doctrine: Limits on Work Injury Claims

Employers owe work injury medical costs only while disability subsists and treatment can still restore capacity, not as lifetime medical coverage. The Medical Expense Cutoff Doctrine limits an employerโ€™s liability for work-related medical expenses once the employeeโ€™s compensable disability has already reached the point where treatment can no longer restore him to work or to […]

Employers Cannot Deduct Uncalled Stock Subscriptions From Wages

Employers cannot offset final pay with unpaid stock subscriptions unless the corporate debt is due, properly called, and deductible under labor law. Employees who are also shareholders do not automatically lose their wages to alleged unpaid stock subscriptions. Before an employer may withhold or offset salary, benefits, or allowances, the claim must belong in the […]

Government-Owned Corporations Without Original Charters Remain Under Labor Jurisdiction

GOCC employees may sue before labor tribunals when the corporation lacks an original charter and is organized under general corporation law. Employees of a government-owned or controlled corporation are not automatically civil service employees. When the corporation has no original charter and was organized under the general corporation law, disputes over wages, separation pay, retrenchment […]