When Franchise Tax Exemptions Survive Local Real Property Tax Assessments

Congress may restore a franchise real property tax exemption after the Local Government Code, but only for assets actually used in franchise operations. Telecommunications companies and other franchise holders may resist local real property tax assessments when Congress has restored a specific exemption for properties actually, directly, and exclusively used in the operation of the […]

When Tax Officials Challenge a Conviction, Procedural Rules Cannot Be Invented Against Them

Supreme Court held that Sandiganbayan could not reject a tax reassessment conviction appeal motion for lacking a hearing date under the wrong rule. Public officers convicted over local tax reassessment actions may still obtain appellate review when their motion for reconsideration was rejected under a procedural requirement that the Sandiganbayan rules did not actually impose. […]

When Taxpayers Can Challenge Local Government Spending in Court

Taxpayers must prove direct injury or illegal public spending before challenging LGU ordinances; taxpayer status alone is not enough for standing. A taxpayer cannot automatically sue a local government simply because public money is involved. To challenge an ordinance, appropriation, or public project, the taxpayer must show a sufficient interest, such as illegal expenditure of […]

Eminent Domain Compliance Doctrine: SC Invalidates Pasig Expropriation

Supreme Court rules Pasig City failed to make valid offer before expropriation; strict compliance with Section 19 R.A. 7160 required for eminent domain. Property owners in the Philippines now have reinforced protection against improper expropriation after the Supreme Court clarified the strict requirements for eminent domain under local law. The ruling underscores that municipalities cannot […]

Eminent Domain Writ: Ministerial Issuance Upon Compliance

The SC ruled that LGUs can obtain a writ of possession for eminent domain once the complaint is sufficient and the deposit is made, without a prior hearing. Local government units (LGUs) exercising eminent domain can now secure a writ of possession immediately upon meeting the statutory requirements, without the need for a prior hearing. […]

No Extrajudicial Closure: LGUs Cannot Shut Down Taxpayers at Will

LGUs may collect local taxes, but cannot close a business extrajudicially when lawful collection remedies and due process apply. The No Extrajudicial Closure Doctrine protects businesses from being shut down by a local government merely because of unpaid local taxes or permit fees. Even when a business is wrong about a claimed tax exemption, the […]

Power Producers Cannot Hide Behind Expired Tax Holidays or Government Tax Exemptions

BOI tax holidays run from registration, not operations; expired incentives and withdrawn GOCC exemptions cannot defeat lawful local business tax assessments. Businesses operating under BOT arrangements may still face local business taxes when their tax holiday has expired, even if a government corporation agreed to shoulder the tax burden. The ruling confirms a hard lesson […]

Electric Cooperatives Can Lose Local Tax Exemptions Without Violating the Constitution

Electric cooperatives under P.D. 269 may lose local tax exemptions when Congress validly withdraws them; no equal protection or contract impairment violation was found. Tax exemptions granted to electric cooperatives are not permanent shields against later legislation: when Congress validly narrows or withdraws an exemption, a cooperative cannot defeat local taxation simply by invoking equal […]

Local Franchise Tax Rule: When LGUs May Tax Government Corporations

Local governments may tax franchise receipts of GOCCs when prior exemptions were withdrawn and proprietary franchise activity is involved. The Local Franchise Tax Rule confirms that a government-owned corporation may still face local business taxes when it operates through a franchise and performs proprietary, revenue-generating functions. For cities and government corporations, the practical lesson is […]

Government Corporations Can Be Taxed Locally When Congress Withdraws Their Exemption

Government corporations may be liable for local franchise tax when the Local Government Code withdraws prior tax exemptions and no express exception applies. Government-owned or controlled corporations can no longer assume that public ownership alone shields them from local taxes. When Congress withdrew most statutory tax exemptions under the Local Government Code, even a national […]