Strict Tax Exemption Rule: Why PLDT Lost Its Local Tax Claim

Tax exemptions in franchises must be clear and cannot be implied; PLDT remained liable for Davao franchise tax despite later telecom laws and equality clauses. The Strict Tax Exemption Rule means that a company cannot escape local taxes by relying on broad franchise language, implied privileges, or equal-treatment clauses unless the exemption is stated in […]

Local Franchise Taxes Still Apply Unless Congress Clearly Says Otherwise

Franchise holders remain liable for local taxes unless Congress grants a clear exemption. PLDT failed to recover Davao franchise taxes. Businesses operating under a legislative franchise cannot avoid local franchise taxes by relying on broad equality clauses, old exemptions, or favorable language in another company’s franchise. A tax exemption must be clear, express, and unmistakable; […]

Market Stall Fees Can Be Challenged When the Numbers Are Disputed

Market vendors may challenge city stall fees when affordability, fairness, and rate computations are disputed; factual issues require trial, not summary judgment. Local governments may impose market stall rentals and other revenue measures, but affected vendors are not powerless when the amounts appear excessive, inequitable, or unsupported by the required process. When the legality of […]

Local Governments Can Franchise Tricycles, But They Cannot Take Over LTO Registration and Driver Licensing

Cities may franchise tricycles, but they cannot replace LTO vehicle registration or driver licensing through local tax or regulatory ordinances. A city may regulate and franchise tricycles for local transport, but it cannot require tricycle owners and drivers to obtain local vehicle registration and driver licenses in place of those issued by the Land Transportation […]

When a Province Donates Land for a Hall of Justice, Acceptance Must Still Be Formal

Public land donations require formal acceptance, donor authority, and proper documentation before a government property transfer can be safely completed. Public land donations for courthouses and halls of justice do not become complete merely because a local government approves and signs a deed. The receiving institution must formally accept the donation, identify an authorized signatory, […]

Local Franchise Taxes Can Override Old Tax Exemptions: What Businesses With Franchises Need to Know

Franchise holders cannot rely on old tax-exemption clauses when Congress withdraws them. Local governments may impose valid franchise taxes under the Local Government Code. Businesses operating under legislative or regulatory franchises cannot assume that old tax-exemption language will permanently shield them from local franchise taxes. A franchise tax exemption is generally a statutory privilege, not […]

When City Franchise Taxes Override Old Tax Exemptions

The Supreme Court upheld San Pablo City’s franchise tax on MERALCO, ruling that the Local Government Code withdrew old franchise tax exemptions. Businesses operating under old legislative franchises cannot assume that historic tax exemptions will protect them from local franchise taxes. The Supreme Court confirmed that the Local Government Code withdrew many earlier tax incentives […]

Airport Authorities Cannot Rely on Old Charter Tax Exemptions After the Local Government Code

Old charter tax exemptions of GOCCs may be withdrawn by the Local Government Code; MCIAA’s airport properties were held taxable by Cebu. Government-owned or controlled corporations cannot assume that an old charter exemption will protect their real properties from local real property tax. When the Local Government Code took effect, prior tax exemptions were withdrawn […]

Zoning Classification Prevails: When Tax Declarations Lose

Tax declarations do not control zoning use; local commercial classification and actual use may defeat permit challenges in property disputes. The Zoning Classification Prevails Doctrine protects businesses and property owners from having valid local zoning approvals undone merely because a nearby property is described differently in a tax declaration. For land use disputes in the […]

Public Plaza Nuisance Doctrine: When Demolition Must Wait

Public plaza structures may be nuisances, but demolition must wait when cadastral ownership and private rights remain unresolved. The Public Plaza Nuisance Doctrine protects municipalities that need to clear public land for public use, but it also warns government officials that demolition cannot be rushed when ownership is still unresolved. For property owners, local governments, […]