When a Stock Sale Challenge Becomes Moot: Lessons for Public Funds, Tender Offers, and Corporate Restructuring

The Court dismissed the SSS share sale challenge as moot after a tender offer and merger erased the original shares, reshaping the transaction and available relief. A lawsuit challenging the sale of government-held shares may lose its purpose when the very shares being contested disappear through a merger, tender offer, or corporate restructuring. For investors, […]

When Listed Shares Are Sold Through the Stock Exchange, Corporations Cannot Block Registration Without Good Cause

Fully paid buyers of listed shares may compel registration; sequestration alone does not make shares government-owned, and stock exchange sales may satisfy bidding concerns. Fully paid buyers of listed shares have a enforceable right to registration in the corporation’s stock and transfer books, and a corporation cannot refuse transfer merely by raising unresolved doubts about […]

A Court Order Is Not Enough: Why Injunction Bonds Can Decide Corporate Control Fights

The Supreme Court held that a preliminary injunction needs a timely bond before it can stop a corporate share sale or support contempt claims. A party trying to stop a disputed corporate share sale must do more than obtain an order saying the sale should be enjoined; the required injunction bond must be filed and […]

RR No. 5-2007: Tax Rules for PDEx Fixed-Income Securities Borrowing and Lending Transactions

RR No. 5-2007 sets BIR tax, registration, reporting, and penalty rules for PDEx fixed-income securities borrowing and lending transactions. Participants in the PDEx Fixed-Income Securities Lending Program must register the Master Securities Lending Agreement and their Participation Agreements with the BIR before entering into securities borrowing and lending transactions if they want the intended tax-free […]

Late SEC Appeals Can End Investment Recovery Cases Before the Merits Are Reopened

Late SEC appeals may fail under either old or new rules, while officers may be personally liable if they assented to unlawful corporate acts. Parties who lose before an administrative hearing officer cannot preserve their appeal by mixing old and new procedural rules, especially where one rule treats a motion for reconsideration as prohibited and […]

RR No. 10-2006: Tax-Free Treatment for Qualified Securities Borrowing and Lending Transactions on PSE-Listed Shares

RR No. 10-2006 grants conditional tax-free treatment to qualified PSE securities borrowing and lending, subject to BIR-approved MSLA registration and reporting. Securities borrowing and lending transactions involving Philippine Stock Exchange-listed shares may avoid stock transaction tax, capital gains tax, and documentary stamp tax only if the parties comply with the strict requirements of RR No. […]

A Corporation Cannot Escape Member Suits by Claiming It Was Dormant or Informally Dissolved

Members expelled without due process may pursue an intra-corporate case despite claims of dormancy or informal dissolution by corporate officers. Corporate officers and association leaders cannot defeat a member’s complaint simply by saying the organization was dormant, unregistered in practice, or already informally dissolved. Where members sue officers over expulsion from membership, loss of franchise […]

When a Court Order Hands Over Company Property Without a Hearing, It Can Be Voided

A corporate faction cannot use an emergency order to seize disputed company property without notice, hearing, and bond, though receivership may preserve assets. A party fighting over corporate control cannot be forced to surrender factories, buildings, machines, and corporate records through an emergency order that effectively decides possession before the opposing side is heard. The […]

When Stock Issuances Are Not Automatically Exempt from SEC Registration Fees

Corporations issuing authorized but unissued shares are not automatically exempt from SEC registration rules or fees, even when shares go only to existing stockholders. Corporations cannot assume that issuing previously authorized but unissued shares to existing stockholders is automatically exempt from securities registration requirements or related SEC fees. The ruling draws a practical line between […]

When Investors Sue a Collapsed Financing Company, the SEC May Be the Proper Forum

Investor claims against a failed financing company may fall under SEC jurisdiction when tied to fraud, licensing issues, and receivership. Investors who lose money in a failed financing company may not always recover by immediately enforcing collection judgments in the regular courts. When the claim is tied to alleged fraud, misrepresentation, a revoked financing license, […]