When Tax Transparency Goes Too Far: Supreme Court Protects Stock Investors From Overbroad Alphalist Disclosure Rules

Supreme Court voided BIR and SEC alphalist rules requiring investor-level dividend disclosure, citing due process, privacy, and agency authority limits. Tax regulators cannot force listed companies, brokers, and market intermediaries to disclose individual stock investors’ personal information through sweeping alphalist rules unless the regulation is validly issued, respects privacy safeguards, and stays within the agency’s […]

Direct Recourse Fact Bar: Why SC Dismissed a Securities Challenge

Supreme Court says securities challenges need standing and fact-ready filing; direct SC recourse fails when monopoly claims require evidence. The Direct Recourse Fact Bar means that even a nationally important securities dispute can be dismissed if the petitioners cannot show personal injury and if the case requires fact-finding that belongs in the lower courts. For […]

When a Corporation Can Reduce Capital Stock Without Unanimous Stockholder Consent

The Supreme Court upheld Sinophil’s capital reduction, ruling that Section 38 compliance, not unanimous stockholder consent, controls SEC approval. Minority stockholders cannot block a corporation’s reduction of authorized capital stock merely because they disagree with the business decision, so long as the corporation complies with the statutory requirements, secures the required two-thirds stockholder vote, protects […]

RMC No. 95-2017: Tax Rules for Government Securities Repo Transactions Under the GMRA

RMC No. 95-2017 exempts GS repo transactions under the GMRA from DST but imposes 20% FWT, GRT, reporting, and audit compliance duties. Government Securities Eligible Dealers participating in the Government Securities Repurchase Program must treat repo transactions under the Global Master Repurchase Agreement as DST-exempt, but they must still account for 20% final withholding tax […]

Filipino Control of Public Utilities: Why Voting Power and Beneficial Ownership Must Both Be Counted

Public utilities satisfy the 60-40 rule when Filipinos hold 60% of voting rights and total capital, not necessarily each share class. Public utility companies may satisfy the Constitution’s Filipino ownership requirement when Filipino nationals hold both 60 percent of the voting shares and 60 percent of the total outstanding capital stock, even if the 60-40 […]

When Corporate Mismanagement Triggers SEC Intervention: Minority Stockholders Can Ask the Regulator to Step In

The Supreme Court upheld SEC power to investigate corporate mismanagement and create a management committee despite intra-corporate allegations. Minority stockholders are not confined to ordinary intra-corporate litigation when alleged corporate mismanagement threatens company assets, public interest, or the survival of the business itself. The Supreme Court recognized that the Securities and Exchange Commission may still […]

Proxy Fights Over Corporate Director Elections Belong in Court, Not the SEC

Proxy disputes tied to director elections belong in regular courts, not the SEC, even when framed as proxy-solicitation violations. Stockholders challenging proxies used to elect corporate directors must bring the dispute before the regular courts, not the Securities and Exchange Commission. Even when the objection is framed as a violation of SEC proxy-solicitation rules, the […]

Insider Trading Rules Apply Even Without SEC Implementing Regulations

SEC v. Interport holds that insider trading and disclosure duties under securities law apply even without implementing rules, allowing SEC investigation. Corporate insiders cannot escape investigation for trading on undisclosed, market-moving information simply because the regulator had not yet issued detailed implementing rules. The practical doctrine is direct statutory enforceability: when a securities law is […]

RMC No. 73-2007: Capital Gains Tax Treatment for Prearranged Block Sales of Listed Shares Through the Stock Exchange

RMC No. 73-2007 taxes prearranged block sales of listed shares as capital gains transactions, even when routed through the stock exchange. Prearranged sales of listed shares, including block sales where the buyer is predetermined, should not be treated as ordinary stock exchange trades merely because the transaction passes through the Philippine Stock Exchange. For companies, […]