BIR Appeals Can Fail Without OSG Authority in Tax Assessment Cases

A BIR assessment appeal was dismissed after the Commissioner failed to prove OSG authority for BIR counsel, reinforcing strict procedural compliance in CTA cases. Taxpayers facing a government appeal in a tax assessment case should scrutinize not only the alleged tax liability, but also whether the government’s petition was filed by lawyers with proper authority. […]

Banana Exporter Loses VAT Refund for Unmatched Foreign Currency Remittances

Exporter’s Php2.43M VAT refund was denied after foreign currency remittances could not be matched to claimed zero-rated sales. Exporters claiming input VAT refunds must be able to trace each zero-rated sale to the corresponding foreign currency remittance; bank certifications showing lump-sum remittances may not be enough if the Court cannot match the payments to the […]

Late Appeals Can End Criminal Tax Cases Before the Merits Are Heard

A criminal tax appeal was dismissed as late because the 15-day period ran from DOJ receipt, not BIR receipt, leaving the CTA En Banc without jurisdiction. Government prosecutors, BIR officers, and accused taxpayers in criminal tax cases must treat appeal deadlines as jurisdictional: once the 15-day period is missed, the Court of Tax Appeals En […]

Taxpayers Can Recover Compromise Payments After Final Cancellation of Assessments

Taxpayers may recover BIR compromise payments after final assessment resolution if the refund right ripens later and claims are timely filed. Taxpayers that paid a compromise offer for a disputed assessment may still recover the amount if the assessment is later finally resolved with no remaining liability to which the payment can be applied. The […]

Importers Must Exhaust Customs Remedies Before Going to the Tax Court

Importers must exhaust BOC remedies before CTA review. The Court upheld abandonment of rice shipments after missed customs appeal deadlines. Importers facing abandonment, forfeiture, or auction of shipments cannot treat the Court of Tax Appeals as the first stop after an adverse customs action. When customs rules provide an administrative appeal route, the importer must […]

Cyber Libel Must Be Filed Within One Year From Discovery, Not Fifteen Years

Cyber libel prescribes in one year from discovery, while unsigned Supreme Court resolutions bind only parties and do not create precedent. People accused of cyber libel now have a clearer prescription defense: even if the allegedly defamatory statement was posted online, the criminal case must still be commenced within one year from discovery by the […]

Renewable Energy VAT Refunds: Hydropower Sales Qualified, Ancillary Services Did Not

Renewable energy VAT refund claims must separate hydropower sales from ancillary services; only valid zero-rated sales supported the partial refund. Renewable energy companies claiming VAT refunds must separate true sales of power or fuel generated from renewable sources from related services, because only the former may qualify for zero-rating. In this ruling, the taxpayer recovered […]

Condominium Associations Can Challenge Local Business Taxes on Association Dues

Condominium association dues used for common-area upkeep were not subject to local business tax, and the refund claim was timely under Section 196. Condominium corporations assessed local business tax on association dues may have a viable refund remedy when the collections are for common-area maintenance and governance rather than profit-making business activity. The decision is […]