Foreign Royalty Refunds Can Fail When the Underlying Agreement Is Not Properly Authenticated

A withholding agent may file an FWT refund claim, but the refund failed because the franchise fee agreement was not properly authenticated as evidence. Philippine companies claiming a refund of final withholding tax on cross-border royalty or franchise fee payments must prove not only that the tax was paid on time and that the refund […]

VAT Refund Appeals Can Be Lost on Procedure Even When the Refund Award Survives

CTA affirmed a P139.45M VAT refund award but dismissed the taxpayer’s appeal for skipping a required motion for reconsideration of an amended decision. Taxpayers pursuing VAT refunds before the Court of Tax Appeals must treat amended decisions as new appealable rulings requiring a prior motion for reconsideration; failure to do so can forfeit the taxpayer’s […]

Improper Service of a Preliminary Assessment Notice Can Void a BIR Tax Assessment

A defective PAN service by registered mail led to cancellation of a BIR assessment, reinforcing due process defenses in tax assessment disputes. Businesses facing deficiency tax assessments should carefully verify how the Preliminary Assessment Notice was served, because an assessment may be cancelled when the tax authority cannot prove that the taxpayer or its authorized […]

Customs Smuggling Charges Can Proceed When Prosecutors Cure Documentary Gaps on Reconsideration

Customs charges were revived after prosecutors cured missing records, leading to probable cause, arrest warrants, and bail in a Tariff and Customs Code case. Importers, customs brokers, traders, and company officers facing customs enforcement should not assume that a case is permanently over merely because an Information was first dismissed for insufficient supporting documents. Where […]

Real Property Tax Protests Must Follow Local Assessment Remedies Before Going to Court

Real property tax challenges involving factual issues must follow pay-under-protest and assessment board remedies, or the assessment may become final. Taxpayers contesting real property tax assessments cannot bypass the local assessment appeal process when their challenge depends on factual questions about the nature, classification, use, or taxability of the property assessed. A taxpayer that goes […]

Tax Assessment Appeals Can Be Dismissed When Proof of Authority Is Not Filed

A tax assessment appeal was dismissed after the Commissioner failed to submit proof of authority, showing how CTA procedural compliance can decide tax cases. A tax assessment appeal can fail before the merits are ever reached if the party seeking review ignores a court directive to prove authority to file. For taxpayers facing BIR assessments, […]

Excise Tax Refunds on Petroleum Sales Require Proof Linking Imported Fuel to Tax-Exempt Buyers

Petroleum importers claiming excise tax refunds must prove that taxed imported fuel was the same fuel sold to PEZA, SBMA, or other exempt buyers. Importers claiming excise tax refunds on petroleum products sold to PEZA, SBMA, or other tax-exempt entities must do more than prove importation, tax payment, and exempt sales. They must establish a […]

Underdeclaration Alone Does Not Save a Prescribed BIR Assessment

A 30% underdeclaration is only prima facie evidence of fraud; without proof of fraud, the BIR cannot rely on the 10-year assessment period. Taxpayers facing old BIR assessments should carefully examine prescription because a 30% underdeclaration, by itself, does not automatically give the Commissioner ten years to assess. In this ruling, the Court of Tax […]

Deficiency VAT Assessments Can Fail When the BIR Misses Quarterly Prescription and Ignores Taxpayer Defenses

Deficiency VAT assessments may be cancelled when the BIR misses quarterly prescription periods or fails to evaluate taxpayer defenses before final assessment. Businesses facing a BIR tax assessment should not treat a Final Assessment Notice as automatically valid. In this assessment dispute involving an electric cooperative, the tax court emphasized two taxpayer defenses that can […]