Criminal Tax Charges Can Be Dismissed When Prosecutors Wait Too Long

A criminal tax case was dismissed despite no prescription because prosecutors failed to justify a decade-long delay after probable cause was found. Tax prosecutors must move with reasonable dispatch even in cases involving alleged violations of the Tax Code, because an unexplained decade-long delay can defeat a criminal tax prosecution even when the governmentโ€™s right […]

Late Tax Protest Leaves 2018 BIR Assessment Final and Unappealable

A late-filed protest to a BIR Final Assessment Notice made the 2018 deficiency tax assessment final, executory, and beyond CTA review. Taxpayers who receive a Final Assessment Notice cannot rely on the date appearing on a protest letter; they must prove that the protest was actually filed within 30 days from receipt. In this assessment […]

VAT Refund Claims Fail When Group Netting Arrangements Are Not Clearly Proven

CTA denied reconsideration of a VAT refund claim because the taxpayer failed to prove valid foreign currency payment through intercompany offsetting. Taxpayers claiming VAT refunds or tax credits for zero-rated services must be ready to prove not only that the customer is a non-resident foreign corporation, but also that the services were actually paid for […]

BIR Assessments Can Be Voided When Taxpayers Do Not Receive the PAN and FAN

A โ‚ฑ164.38M BIR income tax and EWT assessment was voided for lack of proven PAN/FAN receipt and absence of a valid LOA for the auditing officer. Taxpayers facing a BIR deficiency tax assessment should carefully verify whether the assessment notices were actually served and whether the revenue officer who handled the audit was specifically named […]

BIR Cannot Revive Prescribed VAT and Withholding Tax Assessments Without Proper Notice

The CTA En Banc rejected the BIR appeal, limiting the taxpayerโ€™s liability after finding prescription, valid export zero-rating, and withholding defenses. Taxpayers facing old BIR assessments should closely examine both prescription and the written basis of the assessment because the government cannot simply invoke the 10-year assessment period after the fact. Where the assessment notices […]

Mutual Benefit Associations May Challenge Local Business Tax Assessments Imposed as Insurance Company Taxes

Mutual benefit associations may challenge local business tax imposed as insurance company tax when the assessment lacks legal basis and proper classification. Mutual benefit associations assessed local business tax as insurance companies should carefully examine the legal basis of the assessment, the wording of the local revenue code, and whether the tax order is a […]

Foreign Royalty Refunds Can Fail When the Underlying Agreement Is Not Properly Authenticated

A withholding agent may file an FWT refund claim, but the refund failed because the franchise fee agreement was not properly authenticated as evidence. Philippine companies claiming a refund of final withholding tax on cross-border royalty or franchise fee payments must prove not only that the tax was paid on time and that the refund […]

VAT Refund Appeals Can Be Lost on Procedure Even When the Refund Award Survives

CTA affirmed a P139.45M VAT refund award but dismissed the taxpayerโ€™s appeal for skipping a required motion for reconsideration of an amended decision. Taxpayers pursuing VAT refunds before the Court of Tax Appeals must treat amended decisions as new appealable rulings requiring a prior motion for reconsideration; failure to do so can forfeit the taxpayerโ€™s […]

Improper Service of a Preliminary Assessment Notice Can Void a BIR Tax Assessment

A defective PAN service by registered mail led to cancellation of a BIR assessment, reinforcing due process defenses in tax assessment disputes. Businesses facing deficiency tax assessments should carefully verify how the Preliminary Assessment Notice was served, because an assessment may be cancelled when the tax authority cannot prove that the taxpayer or its authorized […]