Corporate officers removed from by-law-created positions must pursue intra-corporate remedies, not ordinary NLRC illegal dismissal claims for reinstatement and backwages.

Corporate officers who are removed from positions created by a corporation’s by-laws cannot automatically treat the dispute as an ordinary illegal dismissal case. When the controversy concerns the election, appointment, or removal of a corporate officer, jurisdiction belongs to the corporate-regulatory forum identified by law, not to the Labor Arbiter or the NLRC, even if the officer asks for reinstatement, backwages, and damages.

Why This Ruling Matters to Executives and Employers

The practical lesson is simple but often overlooked: job title is not the only question. A manager, vice-president, or general manager may look like an employee for many day-to-day purposes, but if the position is an office created by the corporation’s charter or by-laws, a dispute over removal from that office may be treated as an intra-corporate controversy. That classification changes the forum, the procedure, and the litigation strategy.

For executives, this means that a claim for illegal dismissal may fail before it even reaches the merits if the real controversy is removal from a corporate office. For corporations, it means that a termination or removal involving senior officers must be handled with attention not only to labor law, but also to corporate governance documents, board authority, and the statutory rules on intra-corporate disputes.

Background: A Senior Officer Challenges His Termination

Armando De Rossi was an Italian citizen who served as Executive Vice-President and General Manager of Matling Industrial and Commercial Corporation. He started work on July 1, 1985. On August 10, 1988, the company terminated his employment. He later filed a complaint for illegal dismissal before the Labor Arbiter, alleging that the company failed to secure his employment permit, grossly mismanaged the Philippine office, and then dismissed him without cause.

The Labor Arbiter ruled in his favor and ordered his reinstatement to his former positions without loss of seniority rights, backwages, compensatory and exemplary damages, and attorney’s fees. The company appealed to the NLRC and argued that the Labor Arbiter had no jurisdiction because De Rossi’s positions were corporate offices, making the dispute cognizable by the Securities and Exchange Commission under the then applicable jurisdictional framework. The NLRC eventually dismissed the labor complaint for lack of jurisdiction. De Rossi elevated the matter to the Supreme Court (G.R. No. 108710, September 14, 1999).

The Corporate Officer Jurisdiction Rule

The Supreme Court denied De Rossi’s petition. It held that the controversy was not within the jurisdiction of the Labor Arbiter or the NLRC because the dispute involved the removal of a corporate officer. At the time, Presidential Decree No. 902-A vested the Securities and Exchange Commission with original and exclusive jurisdiction over intra-corporate controversies, including controversies in the election or appointment of directors, trustees, officers, or managers of corporations, partnerships, or associations.

The Court emphasized that the by-laws of Matling Industrial and Commercial Corporation expressly provided for the offices of President, Executive Vice-President, Secretary, and Treasurer, and allowed one person to hold more than one office at the same time. Because De Rossi was Executive Vice-President and General Manager, and because the by-laws made the Executive Vice-President a corporate officer, his removal from office was treated as a corporate matter. The dispute therefore belonged to the SEC, not to the labor tribunals.

Why the Claim Was Not Saved by Prayers for Backwages and Reinstatement

A common misconception is that a case becomes a labor case simply because the claimant asks for reinstatement, backwages, damages, or attorney’s fees. The ruling rejects that shortcut. Jurisdiction is determined by the nature of the controversy, not merely by the reliefs written in the complaint.

Here, the central issue was whether De Rossi could be removed from the offices he occupied under the corporation’s by-laws. That question was inseparable from the corporation’s internal governance and the authority of its board. The Court reasoned that a corporate officer’s removal may occur for various reasons, including poor performance, lack of confidence, breach of duties, or fraud. If the alleged misconduct concerns the officer’s corporate functions and affects the corporation’s affairs, the dispute remains an intra-corporate controversy. It does not become an ordinary employer-employee case merely because the officer also performed managerial work.

Jurisdiction Can Be Questioned at Any Stage

De Rossi argued that the company should no longer be allowed to question the NLRC’s jurisdiction because it had participated in the proceedings and filed pleadings before the labor tribunals. The Court disagreed. Lack of jurisdiction over the subject matter may be raised at any time, even on appeal or after judgment, because consent, waiver, or participation cannot confer jurisdiction where the law does not grant it.

This point is especially important in employment and corporate disputes. A party may spend years litigating in the wrong forum, only to have the case dismissed if the tribunal had no authority over the subject matter from the beginning. The ruling is a warning to both claimants and respondents: forum selection is not a technical afterthought; it can determine whether a case survives at all.

What This Means Today

Although the institutional forum for intra-corporate disputes has changed since the period covered by the case, the core doctrine remains significant. Disputes involving the election, appointment, or removal of corporate officers are treated differently from ordinary employment disputes. Today, counsel must carefully examine the corporation’s articles of incorporation, by-laws, board resolutions, employment contracts, and the actual nature of the controversy before choosing a remedy.

For companies, the ruling highlights the importance of clear by-laws and board documentation. If a position is intended to be a corporate office, that status should be reflected in the by-laws or appropriate corporate approvals. If the position is instead an ordinary managerial employment role, the company should avoid documentation that creates confusion between corporate office and employment status.

For executives and senior managers, the ruling is equally important. Before filing an illegal dismissal complaint, an officer should determine whether the position is created by the by-laws and whether the dispute is really about removal from corporate office. Filing in the wrong forum can delay recovery, increase costs, and expose the case to dismissal regardless of the strength of the underlying claim.

Practical Takeaway

De Rossi teaches what may be called the Corporate Officer Forum Rule: when a dispute centers on the removal of an officer whose position is created by the corporation’s by-laws, the case is not an ordinary labor dispute merely because the officer seeks reinstatement or backwages. The controlling question is the legal character of the office and the nature of the controversy.

This doctrine matters in disputes involving presidents, executive vice-presidents, general managers, treasurers, secretaries, directors holding management posts, and other senior executives. The same facts that may look like illegal dismissal to an employee may look like an intra-corporate controversy to a court. The right claim must be filed in the right forum, supported by the right corporate and employment documents.

Speak With a Makati Labor and Corporate Litigation Lawyer

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, executives, HR departments, and shareholders in disputes involving corporate officers, senior management termination, board authority, intra-corporate controversies, and labor claims. If you are facing a dismissal, removal from office, or executive employment dispute, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult a litigation team that can assess both the labor and corporate law dimensions of your case.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *