Missed Pre-Trial and Late Reconsideration Can End a Tax Assessment Appeal Before the Merits Are Heard

A taxpayerโ€™s assessment appeal remained dismissed after missed pre-trial requirements, late reconsideration issues, and unsubstantiated excuses. Taxpayers challenging a BIR assessment before the Court of Tax Appeals cannot treat procedural deadlines and pre-trial requirements as technicalities. A petition may be dismissed, and the dismissal may become final, when the taxpayer fails to timely seek reconsideration, […]

Taxpayer Partially Wins Challenge to 2015 Income Tax and EWT Assessment

The CTA partially granted Intercrew’s petition, cancelling portions of the 2015 income tax and EWT assessment due to BIR’s disregard of taxpayer defenses, upholding only unchallenged amounts. Businesses operating as local manning agencies must carefully track income and account for all tax obligations, as failure to clearly document revenues or expenses can result in partial […]

Tax Prosecutors Must Prove Assessment Receipt Before Criminal Tax Charges Can Survive

Tax prosecutors lost reconsideration after failing to prove receipt of assessment notices and timely court filing in a criminal Tax Code case before the CTA. Criminal tax cases can fail even before trial when the government cannot prove that the taxpayer or its responsible officers actually received the assessment notices and when the criminal action […]

Partial Win for Taxpayer on 2017 Deficiency Assessments: Key Takeaways for Corporations

The CTA partially granted Retiro Golden Foods’ petition: deficiency income tax, VAT, and penalties canceled due to valid protest; EWT and WTC upheld. Corporate taxpayers should carefully track both the form and content of deficiency tax assessments and administrative protests, as failure to properly contest specific items can result in partial liability. In a recent […]

Deficiency Tax Assessments Can Be Voided When BIR Demand Letters Give Conflicting Due Dates

Tax assessment voided after the BIR issued a demand letter with conflicting due dates and failed to address the taxpayerโ€™s protest arguments. Taxpayers facing BIR deficiency tax assessments should carefully examine not only the amount assessed, but also whether the demand letter clearly states when payment is due and whether the BIR actually addressed the […]

When a Tax Case Can Be Won or Lost Before Trial

Early procedural choices can decide tax litigation before trial, from motions to dismiss and prescription defenses to default, discovery, and pleading strategy. Tax disputes can be decided long before witnesses are presented: a taxpayer, collecting officer, corporation, or government agency may win or lose the case at the pleading stage if the complaint, answer, discovery […]

Taxpayers Cannot Extend the 30-Day Deadline to Appeal a BIR Assessment to the Tax Court

Taxpayers must appeal an FDDA within 30 days; a motion for extension may not preserve the right to challenge a BIR assessment before the tax court. Taxpayers who receive a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment must be ready to file their Petition for Review within 30 days, because asking for extra time may not protect […]

VAT Refund Claimants Must Get the Evidence Right Before Judgment

VAT refund claim partly sustained, but both motions failed; the Court enforced strict invoicing rules and reckoned prescription from zero-rated sales. VAT refund claimants cannot use a motion for reconsideration as a second chance to complete defective invoices, receipts, or supporting documents after judgment. For zero-rated taxpayers seeking a refund or tax credit certificate, this […]

Criminal Tax Liability Dismissed Due to Prescription in 2014 Deficiency Case

CTA dismisses criminal charges for 2014 deficiency taxes due to prescription, highlighting the five-year period and finality of assessments for tax nonpayment. Taxpayers and corporate officers should be aware that criminal actions for failure to pay deficiency taxes may be dismissed if filed beyond the statutory prescriptive period. In a recent decision, the Court of […]

POGO Challenges Require Real Injury, Not Just Taxpayer Objections

Taxpayers cannot challenge PAGCORโ€™s POGO rules without direct injury, illegal fund disbursement, and proper observance of judicial review rules. Taxpayers and concerned citizens cannot stop a government revenue or regulatory program merely by alleging that it is unconstitutional. They must show a real, direct, and personal injury, or a clearly illegal expenditure of public funds; […]