Corporate officers removed by board action may need to sue in the corporate forum, not the NLRC, even when they seek compensation or retainer fees.

Corporate officers who are removed from management cannot automatically treat the dispute as an ordinary illegal dismissal case. When the controversy arises from the removal, appointment, or liability of a corporate officer, the case may belong to the corporate forum rather than the labor forum, even if the officer seeks unpaid compensation, retainer fees, allowances, or similar money claims.

Why This Ruling Matters to Corporate Officers and Employers

For executives, hospital administrators, directors, trustees, and other officers of corporations, the forum where a case is filed can decide whether the case moves forward at all. A person may feel that she was dismissed from work, but the law may characterize the dispute differently if the position is a corporate office created by the charter, by-laws, or board action. In that situation, the dispute is not simply about employer-employee relations. It may be an intra-corporate controversy involving the internal affairs of the corporation.

For employers and corporate boards, the ruling is equally important. The decision recognizes that disputes over the appointment and removal of corporate officers are acts of corporate management. These disputes are not converted into labor cases merely because the removed officer also asks for compensation or claims that the dismissal was unfair.

Background: A Medical Director Removed by the Board

Purificacion Tabang was a founding member, a member of the Board of Trustees, and the corporate secretary of Pamana Golden Care Medical Center Foundation, Inc., a non-stock corporation engaged in extending medical and surgical services. On October 30, 1990, the Board of Trustees issued a memorandum appointing her as Medical Director and Hospital Administrator of the corporation’s medical center in Calamba, Laguna.

Although the memorandum did not state the amount of compensation for the position, Tabang claimed that she received a monthly retainer fee of ₱5,000.00 from the parent corporation and that payment allegedly stopped in November 1991. As Medical Director and Hospital Administrator, she was tasked to run the affairs of the medical center and perform administrative acts related to its daily operations.

In 1993, Tabang was allegedly informed that the Board of Trustees had passed a resolution relieving her as Medical Director and Hospital Administrator and appointing other persons as acting Medical Director and acting Hospital Administrator. She thereafter filed a complaint for illegal dismissal and non-payment of wages, allowances, and 13th month pay before the Labor Arbiter. The corporation moved to dismiss, arguing that the dispute was intra-corporate and therefore outside the jurisdiction of the labor authorities. The Supreme Court resolved the case in Tabang v. NLRC (G.R. No. 121143, January 21, 1997).

The Supreme Court’s Ruling: This Was an Intra-Corporate Controversy

The Court affirmed the dismissal of the labor complaint for lack of jurisdiction, without prejudice to Tabang’s right to seek relief in the proper forum. It agreed with the National Labor Relations Commission that the dispute fell under the jurisdiction of the Securities and Exchange Commission at the time because the charges against the corporation formed part of an intra-corporate controversy.

The Court focused on the nature of the position and the source of the appointment. Tabang was not treated like an ordinary employee hired by management in the usual course of business. She was appointed by the Board of Trustees through a board memorandum to occupy the positions of Medical Director and Hospital Administrator. Under the corporation’s by-laws, the Board had the power to appoint a Medical Director, Comptroller or Administrator, Chiefs of Services, and such other officers as it deemed necessary, and to prescribe their powers and duties.

Because the office was created under the corporation’s governing structure and filled by board action, the Court treated the position as a corporate office. The removal of a corporate officer is a corporate act. The reason, wisdom, fairness, or propriety of the board’s action did not change the jurisdictional character of the dispute. The controversy remained intra-corporate because it concerned the relationship between the corporation and one of its officers.

The Corporate Officer Doctrine

The doctrine may be stated this way: when a person holds an office created by the corporation’s charter, by-laws, or board authority, and the dispute concerns the person’s appointment, removal, or rights as such officer, the case is an intra-corporate controversy rather than a simple labor case.

The Court distinguished a corporate officer from an ordinary employee. An office is created by the charter or by-laws of the corporation, and the officer is elected or appointed by the directors, trustees, or stockholders. An employee, on the other hand, usually holds no corporate office and is generally hired by management, with compensation determined as part of the employment relationship.

This distinction is critical because labor tribunals do not acquire jurisdiction merely because a dismissed person claims compensation. If the compensation claim is intertwined with the person’s status as a corporate officer, the dispute remains corporate in nature.

Why Money Claims Did Not Convert the Case Into a Labor Dispute

Tabang argued that her claims for the monthly ₱5,000.00 payment should place the case within labor jurisdiction. The Court rejected this view. It found that the amount could not be considered compensation for services rendered as Medical Director and Hospital Administrator because the vouchers submitted did not show that the payments were made by the medical center for that purpose. The evidence suggested that the payments were made by Pamana, Inc., a separate stock corporation, and could at most be treated as retainer fees for Tabang as a retained physician.

More importantly, the Court held that even assuming the ₱5,000.00 monthly payment was a valid claim against the respondent corporation, that fact would not remove the case from the corporate forum. The claim was closely connected with the position from which Tabang was removed. It was therefore part of the broader intra-corporate dispute involving corporate office, corporate management, and the board’s authority.

Practical Impact for Executives, Professionals, and Companies

For medical directors, hospital administrators, corporate secretaries, trustees, directors, managers, and similar officers, the ruling warns that a removal dispute must be analyzed carefully before filing. Calling a complaint illegal dismissal will not make it a labor case if the real controversy is the loss of a corporate office. Filing in the wrong forum can result in dismissal and delay, even where the claimant may still have a remedy elsewhere.

For corporations, the ruling reinforces the importance of clear by-laws, board resolutions, appointment papers, and position descriptions. If an office is intended to be a corporate office, the corporate records should show the source of authority, manner of appointment, scope of duties, and board action. Poor documentation can create uncertainty over whether the person is a corporate officer, an employee, an independent consultant, or some combination of these roles.

For professionals serving corporations in specialized roles, the decision also shows that labels are not controlling. A person may be a physician, consultant, administrator, trustee, and corporate officer at the same time. The proper legal remedy depends on which capacity is involved in the dispute. A claim for professional fees may proceed differently from a claim arising from removal as an officer.

Legal Strategy: Identify the Capacity Before Filing

The most important lesson is to identify the legal capacity involved before choosing a forum. Was the person hired as an ordinary employee? Was the position created by the by-laws? Was the person elected or appointed by the board? Is the money claim independent of the corporate office, or is it a consequence of removal from that office? These questions determine whether the dispute belongs in a labor tribunal, a corporate forum, or another court.

Tabang’s case does not mean corporate officers have no remedy when removed. It means the remedy must be brought in the proper forum and framed under the correct legal theory. A party who files in the wrong forum risks losing time, resources, and procedural advantage.

Need Advice on Executive Removal, Corporate Officer Disputes, or Labor Claims?

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, executives, professionals, and business owners in disputes involving corporate officers, board actions, illegal dismissal claims, management removals, and jurisdictional strategy. If you are unsure whether your case is a labor dispute or an intra-corporate controversy, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our litigation and corporate disputes team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *