Arrastre operators bear the burden to prove due care; a clean release receipt does not defeat cargo-loss claims when negligence and prior value notice are shown.

The Arrastre Burden Rule means that a port cargo handler cannot avoid liability for missing cargo merely by pointing to a clean release receipt or suggesting that another party may have caused the loss. When goods are placed in the custody of an arrastre operator, that operator must prove that it exercised the level of diligence required of both a common carrier and a warehouseman. For importers, insurers, customs brokers, and logistics companies, this ruling is a major Philippine cargo loss Supreme Court doctrine on who carries the evidentiary burden when goods disappear inside the port system.

Background: The Dispute

Doosan Corporation shipped twenty-six boxes of printed aluminum sheets to Access International, with the shipment insured by Daehan Fire and Marine Insurance Co., Ltd. under an all-risk marine cargo insurance policy. The vessel arrived in Manila on July 12, 2000, and the containerized van was discharged and stored in the Container Yard of the Port under Asian Terminals, Inc.

After the shipment was withdrawn and delivered to Access International’s warehouse, only twelve boxes were accounted for and fourteen boxes were missing. Daehan paid the consignee’s claim and, through subrogation, sued Asian Terminals and the customs broker. The case reached the Supreme Court in Asian Terminals, Inc. v. Daehan Fire and Marine Insurance Co., Ltd. (G.R. No. 171194, February 4, 2010).

The Supreme Court’s Ruling

The Court denied Asian Terminals’ petition and affirmed the ruling holding it liable for the missing cargo. The Court explained that Daehan, as insurer, stepped into the rights of the consignee after paying the insurance claim. The relationship between the consignee and the arrastre operator therefore had to be examined, and that relationship is comparable to the relationship between a consignee and a common carrier, or between a depositor and a warehouseman.

Because Asian Terminals had custody of the goods after discharge from the vessel, it had the duty to take good care of the cargo and deliver it to the party entitled to possession. The Court held that, in a cargo-loss claim by a consignee or insurer, the burden rests on the arrastre operator to prove that it complied with its obligation and that the loss was not caused by its negligence or that of its employees.

The Court rejected Asian Terminals’ reliance on the broker representative’s receipt of the shipment in good order. That receipt did not automatically defeat the consignee’s right to prove that the loss occurred while the goods were still under the arrastre operator’s custody. The Court also noted that Access International had requested a joint survey while the container was still in the possession of Asian Terminals, but the request was not acted upon before the shipment was released.

Key Legal Principles Established

The Arrastre Burden Rule clarifies three connected principles. First, an arrastre operator is not an ordinary passive custodian. Once cargo is discharged from a vessel and placed in its custody, it must exercise the same degree of diligence required of a common carrier and a warehouseman.

Second, the consignee or its insurer does not carry the full burden of disproving every other possible cause of loss. Once the goods are shown to have been under the arrastre operator’s custody, the operator must do more than suggest that someone else may have caused the loss. It must affirmatively prove due care in the handling, storage, and delivery of the cargo.

Third, contractual limits on liability do not automatically apply when the value of the cargo was already known to the arrastre operator through shipping documents, invoices, packing lists, or documents used to assess arrastre charges and other fees. The Court held that prior knowledge of the cargo value allows the operator to obtain compensation commensurate to the risk and prevents it from insisting on a lower contractual cap after loss occurs.

What This Means for Businesses and Individuals

Importers and consignees should document the condition and quantity of shipments immediately and make written requests for joint surveys when loss, shortage, tampering, or forced opening is suspected. A prompt written request can become critical evidence in a Philippine port cargo loss dispute.

Arrastre operators, port handlers, and logistics companies should treat custody records, inspection requests, and release procedures as litigation-sensitive documents. A signed equipment interchange receipt may help, but it is not a complete defense if other evidence suggests that the loss occurred while the goods were still under their custody.

Insurers should also note the value of subrogation. Once the insurer pays the insured consignee, it may pursue the party legally responsible for the loss. This ruling is therefore important not only for maritime and logistics companies, but also for businesses handling marine cargo insurance claims in the Philippines.

Facing a Cargo Loss Dispute? Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

A business that mishandles a port cargo loss claim may lose the chance to recover the full value of missing goods, while an arrastre operator or customs broker may face substantial liability if it cannot prove due care. These disputes often turn on documentation, survey requests, custody records, insurance claims, and the proper application of maritime and civil law principles.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists clients in commercial litigation, cargo claims, insurance recovery, and logistics-related disputes in the Philippines. Speak with a Makati litigation lawyer for Philippine maritime and cargo loss disputes through MakatiLawFirm.com or consult our Makati office for focused advice on your claim or defense.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *