Corporate Officers Cannot Convert Removal Disputes Into Labor Cases

A corporate officer named in the by-laws must challenge removal in the proper commercial court, not before the Labor Arbiter or NLRC. A vice president named in a corporationโ€™s by-laws cannot treat removal from office as an ordinary illegal dismissal case before the Labor Arbiter. When the position is a corporate office, the dispute belongs […]

Taxable Retirement Benefits: When Labor Claims Meet Withholding Tax

Retirement benefits are taxable if age and service rules are unmet; labor tribunals may still hear disputes over withheld benefit taxes. Taxable retirement benefits may lawfully be reduced by withholding tax when the employee fails to meet the statutory requirements for tax exemption, even if the benefits arise from disability retirement after employment ends. The […]

Casino Workers Must Bring Certain Labor Claims to the Civil Service Commission, Not the NLRC

Casino workers in chartered government corporations must bring employment disputes to the Civil Service Commission, not the NLRC, when civil service jurisdiction applies. Employees of government-owned or controlled corporations created by original charter cannot automatically bring workplace disputes before the NLRC, even when the dispute looks like an ordinary labor case. The decisive question is […]

Certified True Copies in Certiorari Petitions: Why One Missing Stamp Should Not Defeat a Meritorious Appeal

Certiorari petitions need certified true copies of the assailed ruling, not every annex. Van Melle protects meritorious appeals from technical dismissal. Litigants challenging a court, tribunal, or agency ruling by certiorari do not need to secure certified true copies of every pleading and attachment in the record. What must be certified is the judgment, order, […]

Corporate Officers Cannot Convert Boardroom Removal Disputes Into Labor Cases

Corporate officers removed from by-law-created positions must pursue intra-corporate remedies, not ordinary NLRC illegal dismissal claims for reinstatement and backwages. Corporate officers who are removed from positions created by a corporationโ€™s by-laws cannot automatically treat the dispute as an ordinary illegal dismissal case. When the controversy concerns the election, appointment, or removal of a corporate […]

When a Dismissal Is Not a Labor Case: Corporate Officers Must Sue in the Proper Forum

Corporate officers removed by board action may need to sue in the corporate forum, not the NLRC, even when they seek compensation or retainer fees. Corporate officers who are removed from management cannot automatically treat the dispute as an ordinary illegal dismissal case. When the controversy arises from the removal, appointment, or liability of a […]

When a Corporate Officer Is Removed, the Labor Arbiter May Not Be the Right Forum

Corporate officers removed from board-created posts may belong in an intra-corporate forum, not the NLRC, even when they seek reinstatement and backwages. A corporate officer who is removed from an elected or appointed corporate post cannot automatically treat the dispute as an ordinary illegal dismissal case before the Labor Arbiter. When the controversy is rooted […]

When a Vice President Is Ousted, the Case May Belong to the SEC โ€” Not the Labor Arbiter

Corporate officers elected under by-laws may need to challenge removal as an intra-corporate dispute, not an NLRC illegal dismissal case. Corporate officers who are removed from positions created by a corporationโ€™s by-laws may not always have an ordinary illegal dismissal case before the labor tribunals. Where the dispute is inseparably tied to the election, appointment, […]

Wrong Forum, Lost Case: When Government-Linked Employees Cannot Sue at the NLRC

Employees of chartered government-linked corporations may be outside NLRC jurisdiction; dismissal disputes must proceed under Civil Service rules. Employees of government-owned or controlled corporations with original charters cannot bring illegal dismissal claims before the Labor Arbiter or the NLRC, even when the employer performs civic, educational, or non-profit functions. Their remedy belongs under the Civil […]

Government-Owned Corporations Without Original Charters Remain Under Labor Jurisdiction

GOCC employees may sue before labor tribunals when the corporation lacks an original charter and is organized under general corporation law. Employees of a government-owned or controlled corporation are not automatically civil service employees. When the corporation has no original charter and was organized under the general corporation law, disputes over wages, separation pay, retrenchment […]